nuttxpr commented on PR #15852: URL: https://github.com/apache/nuttx/pull/15852#issuecomment-2663645659
[**\[Experimental Bot, please feedback here\]**](https://github.com/search?q=repo%3Aapache%2Fnuttx+13552&type=issues) __Fill In The Commit Message:__ This PR contains a Commit with an Empty Commit Message. Please fill in the Commit Message with the PR Summary. This PR summary does not fully meet the NuttX requirements. Here's a breakdown and suggested improvements: **What's Missing/Needs Improvement:** * **Summary:** While it mentions adding I2S support and DMA, it lacks crucial details: * **Necessity:** *Why* is this change needed? Is there no I2S support currently? Are existing solutions inadequate? What benefits does this implementation bring (e.g., performance, features)? * **Functional Change Description:** Be more specific. Which files were modified? Did you create new drivers? Were existing drivers extended? Mentioning "common layer" is too vague. What common layer? * **How it works:** Explain the interaction between I2S, DMA, and the ESP32 hardware at a high level. What are the key data flow paths? * **Issue References:** Link any related NuttX or NuttX Apps issues. This is essential for traceability. * **Impact:** Listing ESP32-C3, ESP32-C6, and ESP32-H2 is insufficient. You must explicitly answer the impact questions with YES/NO and provide descriptions where necessary. For example: * **New Feature?** YES (I2S support) * **User Impact?** Potentially YES. If users want to use I2S, they will need to configure the driver and potentially write applications to utilize it. Explain how users interact with the new feature. * **Build Impact?** Potentially YES. Will any new Kconfig options be introduced? Will users need to select new build configurations? * **Hardware Impact?** YES. Clearly state the affected architectures (RISC-V), boards (esp32c3-generic, esp32c6-devkitc, esp32h2-devkit), and the drivers involved (I2S, DMA). * **Documentation Impact?** YES. You *must* update the documentation to describe how to use the new I2S and DMA features. State that documentation is included in the PR. * **Security Impact?** Consider potential security implications. Are there any new attack surfaces introduced by this feature? Even if the answer is NO, explicitly state it. * **Compatibility Impact?** Does this break any existing functionality? Does it impact future development in any way? * **Testing:** * **Build Host(s):** Specify your build host details (OS, CPU architecture, compiler version). * **Target(s):** While you listed the boards and configurations, be explicit about the architecture (RISC-V). * **Testing Logs _Before_ Change:** You need to provide logs demonstrating the *lack* of I2S functionality before your changes. This shows that your changes actually address a gap. * **Testing Logs _After_ Change:** The logs provided are a good start, but explain what each part demonstrates. For instance, mention that the loopback test shows data integrity. Consider adding logs showing different configurations or use cases. **Revised Summary Example:** This PR adds I2S support for the ESP32-C3, ESP32-C6, and ESP32-H2 RISC-V platforms in NuttX. Currently, these platforms lack I2S functionality. This implementation provides a new I2S driver leveraging the ESP32's DMA capabilities for efficient data transfer. The driver interacts with the `audio` framework and exposes a standard interface for applications to use. The `arch/riscv/src/esp32` directory contains the core driver implementation, and modifications were made to the common ESP32 HAL to support I2S initialization. This change is related to [NuttX Issue #XYZ] (if applicable). **Revised Impact Example:** * **New feature added?** YES (I2S support) * **Impact on user?** YES. Users will need to configure the I2S driver using Kconfig options and utilize the provided APIs in their applications to access I2S functionality. Documentation is provided in this PR. * **Impact on build?** YES. New Kconfig options are introduced to configure the I2S driver (e.g., DMA channel selection, clock settings). Users will need to select these options to enable I2S support for their target board. * **Impact on hardware?** YES. This affects the RISC-V architecture, specifically the ESP32-C3, ESP32-C6, and ESP32-H2 boards. The I2S and DMA peripherals are utilized. * **Impact on documentation?** YES. Documentation is included in this PR to describe the driver configuration and usage. * **Impact on security?** NO. This implementation does not introduce any new security vulnerabilities. * **Impact on compatibility?** NO. This change does not impact backward compatibility or introduce any known compatibility issues. By providing more comprehensive information and addressing all the required points, you'll significantly improve the quality of your PR and make it easier for reviewers to understand and approve your changes. Remember to replace the placeholders like `[NuttX Issue #XYZ]` with actual issue numbers. -- This is an automated message from the Apache Git Service. To respond to the message, please log on to GitHub and use the URL above to go to the specific comment. To unsubscribe, e-mail: commits-unsubscr...@nuttx.apache.org For queries about this service, please contact Infrastructure at: us...@infra.apache.org
