> On Mar 21, 2016, at 2:08 AM, Quincey Morris > <quinceymor...@rivergatesoftware.com> wrote: > > On Mar 19, 2016, at 18:54 , davel...@mac.com wrote: >> >> What I’m having trouble understanding is how I store the images (whose >> filenames will vary from document to document) with NSFileWrapper. In my top >> level directory do I have my main model file as a JSON file along with a >> file (JSON or plist) that lists all the images and then have an Image >> directory that another NSFileWrapper is used to read/write the images (that >> are stored in the Image subdirectory)? >> >> Or can I simply store all the files without a subdirectory? I still suspect >> I need to have a file with a fixed name (such as image.plist) that tells me >> what all the other filenames are to put in the NSFileWrapper (vs. using >> NSFileManager to ask for the name of all the files). > > There’s no correct answer to these questions. It’s a design problem whose > answer is whatever works best in your use case. I’d recommend you start by > choosing what looks to you like the most straightforward approach, then be > prepared to revise your strategy later if it doesn’t work out well. (The > amount of code relating to file wrappers is likely to be small relative to > the code that generally maintains your data model, so rewriting it shouldn’t > be onerous. However, that suggests it would be prudent not to let the > wrappers propagate too deeply into the model. Keep them as an artifact of the > save mechanism in particular, rather than the data model in general.) >
Ok, thanks again for all your feedback. I took a stab at implementing it yesterday. Everything is in my subclass of UIDocument. The rest of the model is a layer below the UIDocument subclass (i.e., the subclass has a couple instance variables which are the main model) although I did put a few methods in the UIDocument class to add the images since that needs to change the NSFileWrapper. I think I've got it working. Here is how I did it (in case this helps anyone else and in case anyone else sees a problem with this). UIDocument subclass has a NSFIleWrapper instances for each of these: 1. Top level NSFileWrapper directory wrapper. 2. It contains a directory wrapper for a subdirectory named Images where all the image files (that won't be updated often go). I put the method to add an image here so that it could update the NSFileWrapper 3. a NSFileWrapper that contains a single file that is a list of all the image filenames that is added to the top level NSFileWrapper 4. a NSFileWrapper for the rest of the model that will change often and is added to the top level NSFileWrapper Whenever an image is added, I remove the NSFileWrapper in #3 from the top level file wrapper, created a new NSFileWrapper with the new list of images, and then add that to the top level NSFileWrapper. And add the image file to the NSFileWrapper in #2. It appears you must call removeFileWrapper on the top level NSFileWrapper and then add the new NSFileWrapper with addFileWrapper rather than just calling addFileWrapper with the same preferred filename and replacement NSFileWrapper. Similarly with my #4 main data model file, I call removeFileWrapper and addFileWrapper each time a save occurs since this data changes frequently. Since images won't be added as often as the rest of the model is updated, I'm hoping this won't cause these images to be re-written every time a save is performed but I'm not certain how to verify this is the case. Thanks, Dave Reed _______________________________________________ Cocoa-dev mailing list (Cocoa-dev@lists.apple.com) Please do not post admin requests or moderator comments to the list. Contact the moderators at cocoa-dev-admins(at)lists.apple.com Help/Unsubscribe/Update your Subscription: https://lists.apple.com/mailman/options/cocoa-dev/archive%40mail-archive.com This email sent to arch...@mail-archive.com
