Members present: Animesh, topcloud, _ps_, chipc, Humbedooh, jzb, jburwell, jlkinsel_, bhaisaab, serverchief, sudhap
---------------- Meeting summary: ---------------- 1. Preface a. http://wilderness.apache.org/manual.html (jzb, 1) 2. Active Feature Release a. As of this morning, there are 5 open blocker bugs (2 of which are unassigned) and 11 open critical bugs (6 of which are unassigned) (chipc, 2) b. chipc to email Sheng about the outstanding critical bugs for inlinemode (chipc, 2) 3. Active Feature Release: QA Status a. http://markmail.org/message/656hkmmwiggq622n (jzb, 3) 4. Active Feature Release: Doc Status a. chipc to ask someone to provide a test plan for S3 (chipc, 4) b. sudhap to ask Hugo for Nicira test status (chipc, 4) c. bhaisaab file doc bug for CloudMonkey docs (jzb, 4) d. https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CLOUDSTACK-1342 (bhaisaab, 4) e. chipc to email the list to talk about code freeze procedures (chipc, 4) 5. Active Feature Release: Additional Issues? 6. Active Bug-Fix Release (4.0.2) a. https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CLOUDSTACK-1151 (jzb, 6) b. jzb ping Nitin about CLOUDSTACK-1151 (jzb, 6) 7. Master Branch 8. Infra 9. Other? -------- Actions: -------- - chipc to email Sheng about the outstanding critical bugs for inlinemode (chipc, 17:18:57) - chipc to ask someone to provide a test plan for S3 (chipc, 17:28:12) - sudhap to ask Hugo for Nicira test status (chipc, 17:29:42) - bhaisaab file doc bug for CloudMonkey docs (jzb, 17:30:12) - chipc to email the list to talk about code freeze procedures (chipc, 17:35:40) - jzb ping Nitin about CLOUDSTACK-1151 (jzb, 17:42:10) IRC log follows: # 1. Preface # 17:00:52 [jzb]: the bot's a little picky :-) 17:00:57 [jzb]: Good morning all, thanks for joining! Before we get started, a few housekeeping items. 17:01:12 [jzb]: We're using the ASF IRC bot to keep a log/minutes of the meeting. If you have any questions about the IRC bot, you might want to look over this link for more information: 17:01:12 [bhaisaab]: jzb: should we wait for 4-5 mins? 17:01:22 [jzb]: bhaisaab: we can 17:01:23 [bhaisaab]: maybe folks are just coming to join us today 17:01:41 [chipc]: jzb: +1 to giving folks a couple of minutes, perhaps 4 17:01:56 [jzb]: OK 17:03:53 [chipc]: sudhap: good morning 17:04:08 [sudhap]: chipc: good morning 17:04:23 [bhaisaab]: hey sudhap! 17:04:32 [sudhap]: bhaisaab: yes 17:04:45 [sudhap]: has meeting started already?? 17:04:53 [chipc]: we were waiting a couple of minutes 17:05:00 [jzb]: sudhap: we're holding off until five after 17:05:00 [bhaisaab]: jzb: looks like we are good to go, 5 mins are up, 17:05 UTC let's sart! 17:05:00 [sudhap]: Oh Ok 17:05:00 [bhaisaab]: *start 17:05:07 [jzb]: and there we are 17:05:22 [jzb]: I'll rewind a bit 17:05:30 [jzb]: We're using the ASF IRC bot to keep a log/minutes of the meeting. If you have any questions about the IRC bot, you might want to look over this link for more information: 17:05:30 [chipc]: ACTION wishes more people were here today 17:05:33 [jzb]: http://people.apache.org/~humbedooh/asfbot.html 17:05:47 [jzb]: As we discussed last week and on the -dev mailing list, we're going to start working with an agenda rather than going by nicks. We hope this will streamline the meetings a bit to keep them under the 1-hour mark. 17:05:52 [jzb]: Here's the suggested agenda that we'll be following: 17:05:53 [jzb]: http://markmail.org/message/xj3mhepy3pbsud3u 17:06:07 [bhaisaab]: chipc: I may just hhave a solution to that will discuss on my turn 17:06:33 [Humbedooh]: jzb: no n :) 17:06:37 [jzb]: Let's start with the first agenda item 17:06:44 [jzb]: Humbedooh: ? 17:06:51 [Humbedooh]: http://wilderness.apache.org/manual.html :) 17:07:06 [jzb]: Humbedooh: ah, thanks 17:07:06 [Humbedooh]: the other page is outdated 17:07:20 [jzb]: I grabbed that from Chip's email about the ASF Bot 17:07:42 [jzb]: #link http://wilderness.apache.org/manual.html 17:07:50 [jzb]: new manual for the ASF Bot 17:07:50 [chipc]: which Humbedooh's rapid customer focused dev cycle quickly made obsolete 17:08:05 [chipc]: ok - so first topic? 17:08:12 [jzb]: #Active Feature Release # 2. Active Feature Release # 17:08:28 [chipc]: 4.1.0 Schedule update / reminder: 17:08:43 [chipc]: 2013-02-28 is the end of the current phase, which includes the docs completion "target" and is when we shift to a limited update model for the release branch (i.e.: I'll be responsible for cherry-picking any changes) 17:08:50 [chipc]: As for progress, bugs are the top item for me right now. 17:08:57 [chipc]: #info As of this morning, there are 5 open blocker bugs (2 of which are unassigned) and 11 open critical bugs (6 of which are unassigned) 17:09:05 [chipc]: I wanted to go through the blockers and critical bugs for 4.1, and share status for a bit. 17:09:12 [chipc]: Assigned blocker bugs: 17:09:13 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-1228: Unable to Create System Vm's in the VMware Hypervisor setup 17:09:15 [bhaisaab]: jzb: but for every agenda how do we go around, ask everyone or everyone just comments/reports? 17:09:23 [chipc]: This one probably needs someone to collaborate in real-time with Kiran to get it resolved. Venkata is the current assignee. 17:09:37 [jzb]: bhaisaab: everyone just comments / reports as we go through the items. 17:09:43 [bhaisaab]: ok 17:09:44 [jzb]: bhaisaab: at least for now, we'll see how that works. 17:09:50 [chipc]: doing bugs right now 17:09:58 [sudhap]: rayees in US timezone can help if needed for this defect - this is blocking VMWare automation run 17:10:14 [chipc]: sudhap: that would be good if you could get it to happen 17:10:27 [chipc]: next one: 17:10:35 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-1252: Failed to download default template in VMware 17:10:35 [chipc]: I thought this was a duplicate of CLOUDSTACK-1228, but Rayees reports that it isn't. Nitin needs to follow up on status for this one. 17:10:50 [chipc]: I pinged Nitin via the bug today 17:11:20 [chipc]: next: 17:11:22 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-1289: [F5-SRX-InlineMode] Usage stats are not generated for Juniper SRX Firewall in inlinemode 17:11:27 [chipc]: Kishan needs to take a look at this. No updates from him yet. 17:11:41 [bhaisaab]: chipc: so there are two issues, one is the vmware one on 4.1 and I know from nitin that ssvm does not work on master is another issue 17:12:03 [chipc]: so are you saying that 1289 isn't a 4.1 issue? 17:12:11 [chipc]: it's a master branch issue only? 17:12:57 [chipc]: I'll ask on the bug to clarify 17:13:11 [sudhap]: chipc: there are 5 blockers for 4.1 17:13:17 [chipc]: moving on - we have some unassigned blockers that people need to grab 17:13:17 [bhaisaab]: I'm not sure if 128 is 4.1 only, can be reporter confirm, afaik multiple reports around ssvm failure on master were sent for 17:13:24 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-1264 System VM doesnt not have default route. 17:13:24 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-1339 ASF 4.1: Management server becomes unresponsive 17:13:24 [chipc]: We need someone to take each of these up! 17:13:31 [sudhap]: chipc: i will check 17:13:52 [chipc]: sudhap: thanks... and yes, I was going through all 5 17:14:00 [chipc]: the last two aren't assigned, which is a problem 17:14:07 [chipc]: we need a volunteer to grab them 17:14:22 [chipc]: so those are the blockers, as of this morning 17:14:30 [chipc]: ready for the critical ones? 17:14:45 [bhaisaab]: chipc: I'll try athem tomorrow ask folks in the office to take a look in case I'm unable to do that 17:14:54 [bhaisaab]: *them 17:14:55 [chipc]: bhaisaab: thx 17:15:15 [bhaisaab]: but sudhap can you discuss if someone in US timezone can take a look at them 17:15:21 [bhaisaab]: if they can that is 17:15:35 [sudhap]: sure 17:15:42 [chipc]: ok, critical bugs... like I said above, there are 11 open right now 17:15:44 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-1227: cloud-install-sys-tmplt script points to /etc/cloud/management/db.properties which doesn't exist 17:15:50 [chipc]: Need Wido to respond to Rohit's question in this bug. 17:15:57 [bhaisaab]: widodh: you there? 17:16:36 [serverchief]: /etc/cloud/management/db.properties - that was the issue for the longest AFAIK 17:16:42 [chipc]: he hasn't been making the meeting in the last couple of weeks, so perhaps not 17:16:45 [bhaisaab]: chipc: I think we can chery pick it, should work, just a path fix so.. 17:16:57 [bhaisaab]: okay moving on 17:17:12 [chipc]: ok, next up! 17:17:21 [bhaisaab]: chipc: you can assign this to me, totally fixabl 17:17:27 [bhaisaab]: *fixable 17:17:35 [chipc]: The following are all assigned to Sheng, and are tied to the F5/SRX Inline mode feature. They don't have any updates since they were opened. I tried pinging him via the bugs. 17:17:42 [chipc]: bhaisaab: ok, doing it now 17:17:50 [bhaisaab]: chipc: email Sheng cc to ML? 17:17:58 [chipc]: yup 17:18:29 [chipc]: ok, here's that list: 17:18:29 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-1288: [F5-SRX-InlineMode] classCastException during network restart with cleanup option true 17:18:35 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-1292: [F5-SRX-InlineMode] Update network from SRX,F5 as service provideds to VR as service provider does not delete firewall rules from SRX 17:18:35 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-1315: [F5-SRX-InlineMode] Network implement failed with Run time Exception during network upgrade from VR to SRX-F5 17:18:42 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-1321: [Site-to-Site VPN] No events are generated in case of status change in site to site vpn connection 17:18:42 [chipc]: and I'll email sheng and cc dev list 17:18:57 [chipc]: #action chipc to email Sheng about the outstanding critical bugs for inlinemode 17:19:05 [chipc]: and now we get to the unassigned list 17:19:12 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-590 Incorrect Network Gateways Assigned to System VMs 17:19:12 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-1013 running cloudstack overwrites default public/private ssh keys 17:19:14 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-1244 fail to push sysmvm.iso onto xen host 17:19:20 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-1290 listNetoworks API takes too long to respond 17:19:20 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-1293 resetpasswordforVm shows "passsd reset to undefined" 17:19:22 [chipc]: CLOUDSTACK-1337 Zone to zone template/ISO copy fails and template/ISO download also fails 17:19:27 [chipc]: Same as the blockers, we need someone to take each of these up! 17:19:35 [chipc]: so we don't have to triage them on this meeting, but we do need folks to grab them 17:19:52 [bhaisaab]: ACTION o.O more people joining the meeting, welcome! 17:19:58 [Animesh]: Yes I am taking these up, RamG and Abhi should have already assigned some of them in India time 17:20:12 [chipc]: and with that, I'm wrapped on the 4.1.0 release mgmt discussion 17:20:35 [chipc]: Animesh: can folks please grab them themselves? (plus, I pulled the list this morning) 17:20:43 [chipc]: jzb: sub topic time? 17:20:50 [bhaisaab]: okay, just to report for 4.1, the db schema diversions are fixed, rollling upgrades fixed on 4.1 today 17:21:06 [Animesh]: certainly but if its not being watched I can certainly fill in 17:21:20 [jzb]: bhaisaab: was there a bug ID for those? 17:21:50 [topcloud]: is there any way to lock down create-schema.sql? 17:21:50 [bhaisaab]: jzb: yes, 1321 17:21:51 [jzb]: chipc: I believe you've covered overall status, yes? 17:21:52 [chipc]: Animesh: see my email to Sudha on the topic of "assigning" vs "contributors grabbing" bugs 17:22:05 [chipc]: jzb: yes 17:22:20 [bhaisaab]: topcloud: do a git log -p on that file time to time and see if someone changed anything 17:22:27 [bhaisaab]: topcloud: or have a hook # 3. Active Feature Release: QA Status # 17:22:42 [chipc]: bhaisaab: we can't do hooks 17:22:58 [bhaisaab]: jzb: 1312 sorry 17:23:05 [jzb]: anything to report on the QA status of 4.1.0? 17:23:08 [jzb]: bhaisaab: thx 17:23:12 [bhaisaab]: chipc: yes, so just keeping our eyes open 17:23:20 [sudhap]: jzp: QA status - Automation is being run for Xen server and KVM 17:23:20 [topcloud]: bhaisaab: I guess we'll just have to monitor th checkins on that file then. 17:23:35 [chipc]: +1 that 17:23:50 [bhaisaab]: topcloud: or I can do that on my personal git mirror, and even on github 17:23:57 [jzb]: sudhap: but still blocked on VMware? 17:24:00 [sudhap]: Yes 17:24:29 [sudhap]: Even though KVM and Xen were unblocked, there are other defects preventing to run full suite 17:24:50 [jzb]: #link http://markmail.org/message/656hkmmwiggq622n 17:24:57 [chipc]: sudhap: and just to be clear - all are logged as blockers or criticals, right? 17:25:05 [sudhap]: chipc: yes 17:25:12 [jzb]: sudhap: I believe that's the issues right now? 17:25:14 [sudhap]: KVM run is being analyzed right now 17:25:20 [jzb]: (from the link) 17:25:27 [sudhap]: additional defects will be logged by end of day today 17:25:29 [chipc]: jzb: they should be the same as the list I just went through as well 17:25:36 [jzb]: K 17:25:42 [sudhap]: jzb: yes 17:25:51 [jzb]: anything else on that topic? 17:26:12 [jzb]: OK # 4. Active Feature Release: Doc Status # 17:26:42 [sudhap]: need updates from Ilya on the test plan for VMware network Distributed network switch 17:26:44 [jzb]: Radhika sent regrets via the ML but also provided an update 17:26:50 [jzb]: http://markmail.org/message/5v3yrrtfvsnvalg3 17:27:05 [sudhap]: jzb: sorry need status on couple of features 17:27:05 [sudhap]: for QA 17:27:12 [jzb]: sudhap: OK 17:27:20 [chipc]: sudhap: QA for 4.1, right? 17:27:42 [sudhap]: s3 test plan is needed as well 17:27:50 [sudhap]: yes for 4.1 QA 17:27:51 [chipc]: ok 17:28:05 [bhaisaab]: anyone writing a chapter, page on cloudmonkey? or, do we want to have one on cloudmonkey, or just have users point to the wiki? 17:28:12 [chipc]: #action chipc to ask someone to provide a test plan for S3 17:28:35 [sudhap]: for nicira integration, test plan has been posted wanted to check testing status 17:28:50 [chipc]: bhaisaab: best to ask seb 17:29:05 [sudhap]: to me it looks like it covers only the integratioin aspect but hugo has submitted additional stories for nicira - would those be covered as well or not 17:29:12 [sudhap]: may be I will take these to the ML 17:29:14 [chipc]: subhap: can you email that request to hugo? 17:29:14 [jzb]: bhaisaab: probably should file a doc bug 17:29:29 [bhaisaab]: jzb: okay, chipc will do 17:29:42 [chipc]: #action sudhap to ask Hugo for Nicira test status 17:29:50 [jzb]: bhaisaab: I'd be happy to contribute in my copious spare time. *cough* 17:30:08 [bhaisaab]: jzb: me too :) 17:30:12 [jzb]: #action bhaisaab file doc bug for CloudMonkey docs 17:30:50 [jzb]: sudhap: was that everything on QA 17:30:53 [jzb]: looks like we got a little sidelined. Sorry. 17:30:57 [sudhap]: Yes 17:30:59 [jzb]: sudhap: thanks 17:31:37 [jzb]: See Radhika's message for her status on docs 17:31:42 [bhaisaab]: #link https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CLOUDSTACK-1342 17:31:42 [bhaisaab]: done: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CLOUDSTACK-1342 17:32:05 [jzb]: I know I also have a few doc bugs for 4.1.0, and in general we have a lot of work left to do there. 17:32:14 [chipc]: jzb: you had mentioned a "doc sprint" last week 17:32:33 [chipc]: any thoughts on how to get that started, going, whatnot? 17:32:35 [jzb]: chipc: I did, I'm still trying to find a time that works. 17:33:25 [jzb]: Next Friday would be a good day, I think 17:33:32 [jzb]: we can get some people together in person at ACNA 17:33:40 [jzb]: and also via IRC 17:33:58 [chipc]: ok - we'll have to do what we did for 4.0 - cherry pick actively into 4.1 from master for docs during March 17:34:17 [jzb]: chipc: we should be doing that already, yes? 17:34:40 [bhaisaab]: chipc: sooner the better, today some db diversion fix cherry picks resulted in merge conflicts 17:34:40 [chipc]: well, yes, except that the "code" is going to move to a controlled branch model 17:34:47 [jzb]: or anyway - making sure that docs are getting updated in all 3 branches 17:34:55 [chipc]: but docs will need to be more actively merged 17:35:18 [jzb]: chipc: have you already detailed how you want that to work via email? 17:35:32 [chipc]: nope 17:35:40 [chipc]: #action chipc to email the list to talk about code freeze procedures 17:35:42 [chipc]: ;-) 17:35:55 [jzb]: thanks 17:36:17 [jlkinsel_]: ha 17:36:19 [bhaisaab]: :) 17:36:40 [jzb]: OK, next topic 17:36:55 [bhaisaab]: 4.0.2? # 5. Active Feature Release: Additional Issues? # 17:37:27 [jzb]: Do we have any 4.1 issues that weren't covered already? 17:37:32 [chipc]: I think we already hit them 17:37:40 [chipc]: let's move on to 4.0.2 17:37:56 [jzb]: sounds good. I'm going to compress 4.0.2 into one topic unless we feel a need to separate them... # 6. Active Bug-Fix Release (4.0.2) # 17:38:50 [jzb]: We currently have 9 open issues for 4.0.2 17:39:26 [jzb]: Most are documentation issues, one is actually resolved and I just need to mark it 17:40:19 [jzb]: issue #1151 17:40:40 [jzb]: ACTION wonders if that works with this bot or not... 17:40:47 [jzb]: Guess not 17:40:57 [Humbedooh]: CLOUDSTACK-1151 17:41:03 [Humbedooh]: hm, not enabled in this channel then 17:41:11 [jzb]: OK 17:41:11 [Humbedooh]: I'll get that done :) 17:41:25 [jzb]: #link https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/CLOUDSTACK-1151 17:41:34 [jzb]: vmware systemVm template upgrade is missing in 4.0 upgrade 17:41:50 [jzb]: This is assigned to Nitin - I'll ping him and see if we can get a resolution on that. 17:42:10 [jzb]: #action jzb ping Nitin about CLOUDSTACK-1151 17:42:28 [jzb]: All of the issues for 4.0.2 are assigned 17:42:40 [jzb]: It's just a matter of chasing them to resolution 17:42:50 [chipc]: jzb: as always, thanks for doing the bug-fix release management... I know it's harder to get folks attention for it 17:43:10 [jzb]: I'll be flying to LAX tomorrow for SCALE 11x, so I'll try to knock all the 4.0.2 doc bugs out during the flight. 17:43:11 [jzb]: (weather willing.) 17:43:40 [jzb]: chipc: happy to, it's a learning experience 17:44:02 [jzb]: Any other issues for 4.0.2? 17:44:18 [jzb]: OK # 7. Master Branch # 17:44:40 [jzb]: Any issues for the master branch we'd like to discuss? 17:44:49 [chipc]: so I'll start by generally expressing a concern that master gets broken way too often 17:45:02 [bhaisaab]: some know issues to fix: ssvm/cpvm in general agents not up, console-proxy refactor move needs to be fixed 17:45:11 [chipc]: not singling folks out, and I have a todo for today / tomorrow to talk about merge expectations 17:45:34 [jburwell]: what's the status of the systemvm issue? 17:45:48 [topcloud]: still working on it. 17:46:10 [topcloud]: incredible how difficult it is to get an environment up and running on windows these days. 17:46:17 [_ps_]: cpvm did not come up when I deployed the latest master code yesterday .Is that a known issue ? 17:46:25 [jburwell]: my testing is blocked until it is resolved .. 17:46:34 [chipc]: topcloud: I figured out the problem... windows 17:46:47 [topcloud]: chipc: :( 17:46:48 [chipc]: jburwell: are you talking about 4.1 testing? or master branch testing 17:46:55 [bhaisaab]: topcloud: switch to linux or mac! 17:47:02 [jburwell]: 4.1 17:47:10 [topcloud]: jburwell: no it shouldn't block 4.1 17:47:10 [chipc]: jburwell: which bug is your blocker? 17:47:17 [bhaisaab]: topcloud: in hyd only one person is on windows now that too will be switching to mac :) 17:47:17 [topcloud]: my changes is not in 4.1. 17:47:17 [chipc]: +1 to what topcloud said 17:47:32 [jburwell]: my understanding is the agent is not spinning up on systemvms for 4.1 .. is that correct? 17:47:47 [jburwell]: (sorry I have been out to attend to a move/house purchase so just coming back online) 17:47:50 [chipc]: I don't believe that's correct, except for VMware 17:48:02 [bhaisaab]: yes, 4.1 is fine... I ran the db upgrade tests and smoke tests all fine for basic vm life cycle 17:48:25 [jburwell]: bhaisaab: good to know 17:48:25 [chipc]: jburwell: do shout loudly on the dev list if you are blocked 17:48:26 [topcloud]: jburwell: congrats on the house. always a fuss to move though. 17:48:43 [jburwell]: will run my smoke tests later today to ensure I am not blocked 17:48:49 [topcloud]: jburwell: but this is a master branch issue not on 4.1. 17:48:56 [jburwell]: topcloud: thank you thank you 17:49:03 [jburwell]: it is has been an adventure 17:49:34 [jzb]: Any other issues for the master branch? 17:49:43 [chipc]: not from me # 8. Infra # 17:50:10 [jzb]: Any infra issues this week that we need to discuss? 17:50:25 [jzb]: I would be curious about the Planet status, if anyone knows anything? 17:50:42 [bhaisaab]: For master branch just want to ask people to put any change in schema-410to420 for any db related changes and in cleanup put things like delete columns etc. 17:50:48 [chipc]: I was just about to pick on jlkinsel_ about that 17:50:48 [chipc]: ;-) 17:50:48 [jzb]: IIRC we're waiting on input from ASFInfra? 17:52:05 [bhaisaab]: Updates on master from my side, 4.2.0 version fixed in poms, 4.2.0 db upgrade paths added and we've a build systemvm code and jenkins job: http://jenkins.cloudstack.org/view/master/job/build-systemvm-master/ which can be replicated: http://rohityadav.in/logs/building-systemvms/ 17:53:26 [jzb]: bhaisaab: great post. Would you mind adding it to the CloudStack Weekly News for next week? 17:53:41 [jzb]: we should add a section on blog posts. 17:53:58 [jzb]: Looks like that's all on master and infra # 9. Other? # 17:54:26 [jzb]: Any other issues we need to discuss? 17:54:26 [bhaisaab]: jzb: yes I'll do that thanks 17:55:11 [bhaisaab]: oh, folks to follow on twitter, my list: https://twitter.com/_bhaisaab/cloudstack-community 17:56:04 [jzb]: bhaisaab: once folks have had a chance to add their names to the wiki, I'll create a list under the CloudStack account as well. 17:56:26 [bhaisaab]: jzb: yeah that would be great an official list :) 17:56:33 [jzb]: any other issues? Otherwise we can call it a day, in less than one hour! 17:56:41 [bhaisaab]: do it!
