ChenMiaoi wrote: > > > Please review the llvm AI policy, and confirm you are following it. > > > > > > I did read the AI Tool Use Policy, and my understanding was that this > > workflow was consistent with it. If I’ve misunderstood any part of it, I’d > > appreciate clarification. > > To clarify my workflow: > > > > * I use LLMs to help find issues that I find interesting and that don’t > > appear to have an existing fix. > > * I manually reproduce the reported issue locally to check whether it still > > exists or has already been fixed. > > * I use LLMs to help narrow down where the problem might originate. > > * I then write the code and run tests, and use LLMs for an additional local > > code review. > > * When writing PR descriptions, I use LLMs to translate my writing into > > English. > > > > Could you clarify which part of this workflow raises concerns under the > > policy, and what I should change? Does this level of assistance require an > > Assisted-by tag or another form of disclosure? If so, I’ll make sure to > > include it going forward. Thanks for the guidance! > > Ok, my concern is that you have filed a large number of PRs against a wide > array of different areas in llvm (libc and clang). > > Using an LLM for translation is 100% ok. > > I've made the "This PR doesn't appear to comply with our policy on > tool-generated content" on all of your PRs simply due to the number, but if > you have not used an LLM for those PRs then just reply referencing your reply > here and it's all ok. > > It would be better to focus on a single area to build up experience and > knowledge rather than trying to learn everything in the code base all at once.
Thanks for your reply. I understand your concerns about LLM misuse adding unnecessary review work. To clarify why my PRs span both areas: I initially planned to contribute to libc, but later found that I was more interested in Clang’s parsing and diagnostic issues. My recent work has therefore been focused mainly on fixing outstanding Clang frontend issues. https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/pull/229612 _______________________________________________ cfe-commits mailing list [email protected] https://lists.llvm.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/cfe-commits
