Hello, On Mon, 26 May 2014 10:28:12 +0200 Carsten Aulbert wrote:
> Hi all > > first off, we have yet to start with Ceph (and other clustered file > systems other than QFS), therefore please consider me a total newbie > w.r.t to Ceph. > Firstly the usual heads up, CephFS is not considered ready for production due to the non-HA nature of MDS. > We are trying to solve disk I/O problems we face and would like to > explore if we could utilize our currently underused network more in > exchange for more disk performance. We do have a couple of machines at > our hands to use, but I would like to learn how well Ceph scales with a > large number of systems/disks. > It scales rather well, if you search the archives here on the net in general you will find a slide show from your colleagues at CERN. > In a safe approach, we could use 16 big boxes with 12 3 TB disks inside > and explore to use JBOD, hard- or software raid and 10Gb/s Ethernet > uplinks. > You're not really telling us what your I/O problems are and what your goals are, scientific storage needs frequently tend to be huge amounts of data (sequential). OTOH you might want/need more IOPS. > On the other hand we could scale out to about 1500-2500 machines, each > with local disks (500GB-1TB) and/or SSDs (60GB) inside. > This will give you in theory a very high performance cluster, given enough bandwidth between all those nodes. However I'd be very afraid of the administrative nightmare this would be, you'd need a group of people just healing/replacing nodes. ^o^ > For now I have got two questions concerning this: > > (a) Would either approach work with O(2000) clients? > Really depends on what these clients are doing. See above. > (b) Would Ceph scale well enough to have O(2000) disks in the background > each connected with 1 Gb/s to the network? > I'd guess yes, but see above why this might not be such a great idea. Somebody from inktank or one of the big folks is sure to pipe up. Christian > Has anyone experience with these numbers of hosts or do people use > "access" nodes in between which export a Ceph file system via NFS or > similar systems? > > Cheers > > Carsten > > PS: As a first step, I think I'll go with 4-5 systems just to get a feel > for Ceph, scaling out will be a later exercise ;) -- Christian Balzer Network/Systems Engineer ch...@gol.com Global OnLine Japan/Fusion Communications http://www.gol.com/ _______________________________________________ ceph-users mailing list ceph-users@lists.ceph.com http://lists.ceph.com/listinfo.cgi/ceph-users-ceph.com
