Hello, sorry for the long email, it's a little hard to explain this issue. The 
gist of it is that the Ubuntu version of parted allowed me to do something 
which perhaps should not be allowed i.e. creating partitions on a 2.7TB drive 
when the partition table is not *gpt* but *msdos*.

I am trying to configure 2 identical servers, both are Dell Poweredge 2970 
machines with 6 disks in them configured as a RAID 5 with one hotspare, and 
both give me 2.726TB of space after the RAID 5 is configured. There are slight 
differences between the BIOS versions and Firmware versions of the LSI disk 
controller, etc but I'm not sure that matters in this case.

Now, I setup server "A" a few months ago and for some reason that I don't 
remember now I resorted to using a Ubuntu 64-bit LiveCD to create the 
partitions. Since the disk is larger than 2TB, I had to use 'parted' to create 
the partitions. So I happily created the partitions I wanted which are below:

/               50 GB
/var            20 GB
/data           the remainder (a large partition)

Now, after a few months I forgot all about the Ubuntu LiveCD and tried to setup 
server "B" using the CentOS 5.3 x86_64 CD. However the installer immediately 
complained that "this disk in using a GPT partition table and this computer 
cannot boot using GPT" and it keeps saying this no matter what I do. I've tried 
creating a separate /boot partition, using LVMs for everything, etc but nothing 
works, even "dd" did not give me much luck, although perhaps I should try 
deleting the "end" of the disk rather than the beginning?

I have now noticed that when press Ctrl-Alt-F2 on server "B" during the CentOS 
install and attempt to use 'parted' it says that the "label" type is "gpt". It 
allows me to create new partitions, etc but it's no help because the installer 
keeps complaining that the machine will not boot with a GPT partition table. So 
I need to really use a "msdos" partition type to boot this machine 
successfully, but the CentOS version of parted will not allow me to do that.

The additional mystery is that if I check server "A" which I partitioned a few 
months ago using Ubuntu, the "label" type is "msdos"!! How is that possible? In 
addition if I use the CentOS CD and try to use parted on server "A" now, it 
gives the following error:

---------------------------
# parted
GNU Parted 1.8.1
Using /dev/sda
Welcome to GNU Parted! Type 'help' to view a list of commands.
(parted) p                                                                
Error: msdos labels do not support devices that have more than 4294967295 
sectors.
---------------------------

BUT if I reboot this same server (server A) again using the Ubuntu LiveCD 
parted works just fine! It prints the label type as "msdos", and it prints the 
above partition table correctly and gives me the right size for it and 
everything.

So what is going on here? Is the Ubuntu parted somehow buggy and allowing me to 
do something dangerous that I will regret later, or can I just ignore the label 
setting in parted and continue to setup Server "B" the same as "A" and hope for 
the best?

I would appreciate any insights.

_______________________________________________
CentOS mailing list
CentOS@centos.org
http://lists.centos.org/mailman/listinfo/centos

Reply via email to