On Sun, Feb 02, 2025 at 03:29:11PM +0000, Gavin Smith wrote:
> Your initial proposal to make '@set xrefautomaticsectiontitle on' use
> the anchor text for the reference doesn't make sense, as the purpose
> of this option is to use text that appears in the resulting document,
> as Eli says.
> 
> The problem with changing the output for a cross-reference to anchors
> is that some manuals may be depending on the existing output, with
> the anchor names used in HTML output.  So I think we should change
> the output in DVI/PDF instead to match the current HTML output, and
> use the anchor names in the output text.

I see this was previously discussed, although I don't remember this:

> In the anchor reference the corresponding section reference title is
> shown.  IMHO, this doesn't make much sense because it loses context
> – in the example above, how shall the reader know that she has to
> look for 'blubb'?  A better solution is to use the anchor node name
> if #3 of `@xref` is missing, inspite of `@xrefautomaticsectiontitle
> on`.
(Werner Lemberg, 2021-02-20)
https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/bug-texinfo/2021-02/msg00110.html


Reply via email to