Follow-up Comment #13, bug #59402 (group groff):

[comment #12 comment #12:]
> How is it that you were unaware of these facts?  They are not
> recent developments.  If you _were_ aware of them, why are you
> making such distorted claims on a topic that desperately needs
> better understanding by your fellow developers?

This paragraph strikes me as overly harsh.

(1) No one in a volunteer project should be chastised for not knowing
something.  Even the most expert among us is ignorant of some aspects of groff
(or whatever topic one is expert in), especially the arcane parts under
discussion here.  And because it's a volunteer project, all of us are free to
learn as much or as little of it as we want.  Even the most novice can make
useful contributions.  Even the most expert can have knowledge gaps.  There's
no entrance exam.  No one's pay is getting docked.

(2) Calling someone's claims "distorted" comes across as a presumption of bad
faith when there are other, more charitable possibilities -- especially in the
case of Deri, with whom you've had numerous disagreements due to approaching
things from different perspectives (a fact you just pointed out in another
thread).  Asking for clarification about his statements, if something seems
wildly off, is probably a more fruitful, and certainly a less combative,
approach than "why are you making such distorted claims?"  (I'll grant that
you didn't explicitly say you thought the distortion was deliberate, but the
phrasing of that question strongly implies it.)

I hope I'm the one misreading the intent here.


    _______________________________________________________

Reply to this item at:

  <https://savannah.gnu.org/bugs/?59402>

_______________________________________________
Message sent via Savannah
https://savannah.gnu.org/

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: PGP signature

Reply via email to