Paul Eggert <[email protected]> writes: > On 10/19/11 04:06, Simon Josefsson wrote: >> 1) Is there any platform where this has any implications for the ABI? > > OS/400. libcurl ran into this problem; see > <http://multitheftauto.googlecode.com/svn/trunk/vendor/curl/packages/OS400/README.OS400>. > > Android users are constantly worrying about whether to compile > with -fno-short-enums, citing ABI incompatibilities. E.g., see > <http://osdir.com/ml/android-ndk/2010-10/msg00559.html>. > > I expect you'll probably run into an ABI problem somewhere, > though I couldn't find anything specifically on point to your > coding example.
Ouch. :-( Thanks for this information. I feared that the old assumption "enum = int" that I have relied on wasn't really true. It's still not clear to me that my proposed change would break on even OS/400 though, it seems the curl problem was only about varargs? They used a pragma to turn enum into int's, but it wasn't clear that the compiler would pick something else if the pragma wasn't there. /Simon
