Hi Blake,

thanks. Negative powers build on  the concept of an "inverse function".
In GNU APL some of the primitives have inverse functions (+/- ×/÷, ⋆/⍟ 
and ○).
But these inverse functions have rather strange effects, for example:

      2 (+ ⍣ 40) 5
85
      2 (- ⍣ ¯40) 5
85
      2 (+ ⍣ ¯40) 5
5
      2 (- ⍣ ¯40) 5
85

In the context of APL operators (+\ in the Dyalog example), the determination of the inverse function can get very complicated and is undefined in most cases. Given
that I will no go down too far on the road to inverse functions.

When I read about the power operator for the first time (around GNU APL 1.2 or so), it was the concept of inverse functions that made me think of ⍣ as a broken operator.
/// Jürgen


On 08/13/2014 01:53 AM, Blake McBride wrote:
Trying some of the examples in the Dyalog book I found the following:

Dialog book:
      (+\ ⍣  ̄¯1) 3 4 9 15 19
3 1 5 6 4


GNU APL:
      (+\ ⍣ ¯1) 3 4 9 15 19
DOMAIN ERROR
      (+\⍣¯1)3 4 9 15 19
      ^     ^


/Blake McBride/
/
/
www.arahant.com <http://www.arahant.com/>
Cell:    615-394-6760
Office:  615-376-5500
Fax:     615-377-6006




On Tue, Aug 12, 2014 at 12:32 PM, Juergen Sauermann <juergen.sauerm...@t-online.de <mailto:juergen.sauerm...@t-online.de>> wrote:
    Hi,

    I have implemented the first shot at the power operator ⍣. SVN 434.

    /// Jürgen




Reply via email to