[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
>The story of Rachel was unbelievably touching and sad.

No question.  I was completely absorbed in her tale.  I suppose being
a parent myself added a dimension to that as well.  It was like
watching Alzheimer's in reverse, a comparison I think Sol makes as 
well.

>I felt that in the Endemyon books he had jumped the shark (or to be 
>more accurate the Shrike).

"Jumped the Shrike" made me chuckle aloud.  That should be the 
official expression for SF/Fantasy that's jumped the shark.  Spread 
the word!

>I enjoyed these books but they were totally different in tone 
>and style.

I was on the fence about them because it seemed to me that Simmons' 
editor was letting him get far too verbose in some sections, probably 
adding a good 50+ pages of fluff between the two Endymion books, 
which made sections of them drag.  And then I also have a pet peeve 
about authors who change the established rules of their universe 
because it's convenient (that's why I think Goodkind's pretty much a 
hack, excepting the first and sixth SoT books), which I felt Simmons 
did a fair amount of. But the last 50-100 pages of _Rise of Endymion_ 
I found to be incredibly affecting, and they rescued the series for 
me.

Jim

_______________________________________________
Join Excite! - http://www.excite.com
The most personalized portal on the Web!


_______________________________________________
http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l

Reply via email to