[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

> > What's the source of criticism? Comments from an atheist I would
> > analyze differently than comments originating in a Klan rally
> > 
> Any source

But that seems rather unfair to me. If, going by what you say, the fact
of Jewish oppression for two millennia on certain continents gives the
Jews the right to suspect any statement of carrying the seeds of
anti-semitism, then surely, the fact of peaceful co-existence for two
millennia on other continents confers an obligation to suspend that
suspicion. Surely the stand/the standards have to be internally
consistent at least.

Ritu

_______________________________________________
http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l

Reply via email to