Gautam, et al,

I'm writing to retract my previous message. I reject your categorization of me as being out of the mainstream. Moreover, I found your message a little short on what I'll call intellectual honesty.

First, you admittedly pulled your numbers out of your ... um ... head, whereas this thread was discussing *actual* numbers from a poll that has been conducted for 15 years by the Pew Research Center. Guess which ones I consider to have more weight?

Second, your four groups of 20% are skewed to the right. Why didn't you have five groups:

Very Conservative 20%
     Conservative 20%
         Moderate 20%
          Liberal 20%
     Very Liberal 20%
           -- Source: My Ass

Using the above categories, which at least provide a centered spectrum, feel free to provide your own numbers.

Third, I don't understand why your four categories only added up to 80%, leaving out 20% of the population. Do you think that the opinions of 20% of Americans don't count, or that 20% don't have any opinions? That is certainly heading in the direction of at least one finding in the Pew report: 63% of respondents feel that "Most elected officials don't care what people like me think."

Perhaps your story would be better served with these groupings (with no bullshit numbers): Extremely Conservative, Very Conservative, Moderately Conservative, Mildly Conservative, Lunatic Fringe.

Returning to meaningful results of an actual poll, the categories and percentages under discussion are:

Right-leaning:
                Enterprisers  9%
        Social Conservatives 11%
Pro-Government Conservatives  9%

Centrist/Unaffiliated:
                     Upbeats 11%
                Disaffecteds  9%
                  Bystanders 10%

Left-leaning:
      Conservative Democrats 14%
     Disadvantaged Democrats 10%
                    Liberals 17%

As you can see, the Liberals *as defined by the Pew report* are the largest bloc. The "mainstream," one might say.

For the three general groupings that the Pewsters created, the percentages are:

   Right-leaning 29%
Centrist/Neither 30%
    Left-leaning 41%

Thanks,

Dave

_______________________________________________
http://www.mccmedia.com/mailman/listinfo/brin-l

Reply via email to