On 18.07.2006, at 18:47, Alan Brown wrote: > On Tue, 18 Jul 2006, Sebastian Stark wrote: > > >> I also noticed problems with this kind of setup but almost never >> got an >> answer when asking questions about multiple drive autochanger >> issues... >> > > For the most part, this is "esoteric high end use" :-)
Probably. One of baculas strengths however is great scalability (we're at 50TB of backup data at the moment), that's why we use it in favour of other solutions :) > > >> ps I have three drives w/ thre concurrent jobs and spooling and >> very often >> find two of the drives idleing while there are hundreds of jobs >> waiting for a >> free drive. >> > > I am seeing this too. > > Additionally I'm getting multiple-hour hangs when trying "status > director" > in bconsole as it tries to check for jobs waiting to reserve a drive. > > The same hangs occur in the tray monitor. > > > Having observed it for a while, it looks like anything using drive 1 > causes drive 0 to be locked out, but using drive 0 does not lockout > drive > 1. > Sometimes it looks to me like bacula starts three jobs, then waits until *all* of them have finished and starts another round of three. I am not 100% sure yet, but I guess the other jobs wait "on max concurrent storage jobs", which I set to four. I have to find a way to monitor all this. I did not choose different spool directories for each drive, in my opinion one would only benefit from this by having a dedicated hard drive for each tape drive. Am I wrong? I have yet to find a way to reproduce this behaviour. It's a bit hard because you only notice this kind of stuff if you have relatively long running jobs. What I can do is send my configuration so far. bacula-sd.conf: Storage { Name = yangtse-sd SDPort = 9103 WorkingDirectory = "/usr/local/bacula/working" Pid Directory = "/var/run" Maximum Concurrent Jobs = 4 } Autochanger { Name = neo4000 Device = Drive3,Drive4,Drive5 Changer Command = "/usr/local/bacula/etc/mtx-changer %c %o %S %a %d" Changer Device = "/dev/scsi/changer/c4t2100001086119230d2" } Device { # LTO-2 Laufwerk SCSI (NEO: Drive 1) # Used only for permanent pool (LTO-2 tapes only!) # thus autoselect=no Name = Drive1 Media Type = LTO-2 Archive Device = /dev/rmt/2cbn AutomaticMount = yes; AlwaysOpen = yes; RemovableMedia = yes; Drive Index = 0 AutoChanger = yes Autoselect = no Spool Directory = /export/altai0/spool Maximum Spool Size = 429496729600 # 400G Maximum Job Spool Size = 214748364800 # 200G Maximum Rewind Wait = 600 Maximum Open Wait = 30 Maximum Changer Wait = 120 } Device { # LTO-3 Laufwerk FC (NEO: Drive 3) (dmesg: st18) Name = Drive3 Media Type = LTO-2 Archive Device = /dev/rmt/4cbn AutomaticMount = yes; AlwaysOpen = yes; RemovableMedia = yes; Drive Index = 1 AutoChanger = yes Spool Directory = /export/altai0/spool Maximum Spool Size = 429496729600 # 400G Maximum Job Spool Size = 214748364800 # 200G Maximum Rewind Wait = 600 Maximum Open Wait = 30 Maximum Changer Wait = 120 } Device { # LTO-3 Laufwerk FC (NEO: Drive 4) (dmesg: st17) Name = Drive4 Media Type = LTO-2 Archive Device = /dev/rmt/3cbn AutomaticMount = yes; AlwaysOpen = yes; RemovableMedia = yes; #RandomAccess = no; Drive Index = 2 AutoChanger = yes Spool Directory = /export/altai0/spool Maximum Spool Size = 429496729600 # 400G Maximum Job Spool Size = 214748364800 # 200G Maximum Rewind Wait = 600 Maximum Open Wait = 30 Maximum Changer Wait = 120 } Device { # LTO-3 Laufwerk SCSI (NEO: Drive 5) (dmesg: st14) Name = Drive5 Media Type = LTO-2 Archive Device = /dev/rmt/0cbn AutomaticMount = yes; AlwaysOpen = yes; RemovableMedia = yes; Drive Index = 3 AutoChanger = yes Spool Directory = /export/altai0/spool Maximum Spool Size = 429496729600 # 400G Maximum Job Spool Size = 214748364800 # 200G Maximum Rewind Wait = 600 Maximum Open Wait = 30 Maximum Changer Wait = 120 } Sebastian ------------------------------------------------------------------------- Take Surveys. Earn Cash. Influence the Future of IT Join SourceForge.net's Techsay panel and you'll get the chance to share your opinions on IT & business topics through brief surveys -- and earn cash http://www.techsay.com/default.php?page=join.php&p=sourceforge&CID=DEVDEV _______________________________________________ Bacula-users mailing list Bacula-users@lists.sourceforge.net https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/bacula-users