On Tue, Jun 15, 2010 at 14:08, Andrew Bowden <[email protected]> wrote:

> Much as I'm rather loathe to wade into this, there's an important
> question to ponder.
>
> If the alternative was this system did not exist and rights holders told
> broadcasters (for this is not just a BBC issue) that the broadcaster
> could not broadcast their content in HD on the Freeview platform...

Those are _very_ big "if"s. enormous.

The content being talked about (that is, US imports, movies, and the like), are

a) broadcast in other countries without this scheme or an equivalent
b) distributed widely prior to it hitting the UK

couple with that with the fact that the Strategy Review recommends
reducing the budget and amount of bought-in programming, and you're
not look at anything like the gaping holes in the schedule which have
been foretold.

moreover, what happens if the rights holders demand something else?
something that's clearly (not just to us on here, but to BBC
management and the regulators) ridiculous? what if they demanded that
all BBC staff wear HBO[0]-branded baseball caps whenever one of their
programmes is aired on FVHD? do we all go along with it because we're
scared of schedule-gaps, or do we tell them to stuff it, because there
are principles at stake and the proposal is ridiculous?

Don't get me wrong, I could actually understand the position if this
was remotely capable of achieving the publicly-stated aims, but it
cannot possibly be. I can't stress that enough, because it's not an
exaggeration or hyperbole: this scheme, despite what's been said
publicly, has about as much to do with stopping "Internet piracy" as
the ASA's latest advertising adjudication does: nothing. it can't. the
effect it actually has upon pirates is about same as the "Copyright
BBC MMX" at the end of each programme.

So, answer this: what right do the rights-holders have to make these
demands of the broadcaster? (IMO, every right - they can ask anything
they like, but it doesn't mean they'll get it); what right does the
licence-fee-funded public-service broadcaster have to impose them upon
the ordinary consumers (the only people who will be inconvenienced by
them) without weight of merit and to lobby for them? what right does
the telecommunications industry regulator, who is supposed to operate
in the interests of "consumers and citizens", have in approving this
measure?

the BBC had a choice:

a) do nothing

b) do something which didn't achieve the desired effect, and caused
additional negative effects

it chose (b), because the rights-holders threw their toys out of the pram.

now, either this is because the people who know that this is the case
couldn't make themselves heard, or because stopping piracy wasn't the
goal in the first place. which is it?

> ...how would you explain to the average punter that the programme could
> not be broadcast on Freeview HD?  And how would you justify it to them
> in such a way that they went "Yes, you're right" rather than "Eh?"

"The rights-holder won't allow it". Exactly as you do with iPlayer,
although frankly, I'd name names. Only within the industry is there a
conceptual difference between "broadcast" and "on-demand" rights and
differentials.

-
Sent via the backstage.bbc.co.uk discussion group.  To unsubscribe, please 
visit http://backstage.bbc.co.uk/archives/2005/01/mailing_list.html.  
Unofficial list archive: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/

Reply via email to