Whilst I broadly agree with the sentiments expressed wrt freedom of
information, lack of arbitrary 'protections' for content which can only
really benefit the producers by restricting personal use and enjoyment,

> The concerns are not legitimate, you do not have the right to 
> enslave the public, in exchange for secondary sources of revenue.

Enslavement's a bit extreme isn't it David? ;) I hardly feel coerced to buy
all the BBC DVDs when they're released ;)


The BBC's constantly in a pickle over this, and I can't really understand
why it makes such a fuss. (or is it the parties who supply the BBC stomping
their feet again?) The Beeb's a PSB yet it has a commercial profit-making
arm to help amortise the costs of production and/or buying in programming. I
don't have a problem with the BBC making a few extra quid off the DVDs. I
*do* object on principle to the removal of means by which one can enjoy
programming in a free, open way of one's own choosing (and things like the
crypto obfuscation of the EPG data on DVB-T2, breaking an otherwise open
standard, don't help foster good relations). Doing silly things like that
simply drives people to watch via other means (and many years of high
quality TV rips from Sky broadcasts using the analogue hole should have
disproved that argument long ago!)

It's a weird mindset people have these days. I myself have downloaded a show
if I missed it on the iPlayer. I wish there was an accurate means by which I
could submit views of programming - think Nielsen, but for the benefit of
rightsholders. The iPlayer could then just become a torrent tracker, and you
download your vids from that in an open standard and the little app which
runs in your system tray notes when you open a video, how long you watch it
for etc. This could all be managed A typical internal thought process might
go, "why should I be beholden to the 7 day / 2 month / xyz day availability
period? I didn't want to watch it when it first aired, but I want to watch
it now and it's still not available on DVD, so I'll download it. I will NOT
be dictated to as to when I want to consume my media."

And it's that point - "MY media" - where I think this battle's already lost.
I think the trend is to consider it as 'my [favourite] TV' - no more waiting
for months for the boxsets, I want to watch this in HD on my little media
streaming box under my TV in high def and I want to watch at my
convenience... So out comes the torrent client, down loads the H.264 MKV
file and down one sits in front of the box to enjoy the show. Why isn't this
possible already without being forced to circumvent the usual channels of
distribution?


Due to the unique way the BBC is funded, they should be *more* open than any
other broadcaster given their relatively steady funding - for me the
industry-wide excuse of 'oh we've lost sales due to unsanctioned
distribution via P2P etc' was blown right out the water when VCRs reached
critical mass, there's no point trying to lock that barn door as the horse
has not only bolted, it's been captured, tamed and gone on to win the Grand
National.


> Subject to limitations imposed by blackmail from the content 
> industries.
> 
> Perhaps the public should just reject the blackmail, and 
> maintain our freedom. This is a social contract too far, that 
> only meets the needs of special interests.


The discreet lobbying by the major interest parties is something I'm
definitely not in favour of, yet it remains rife industry-wide.

(case in point: having just read the latest BPI Digital Music report it
absolutely reeks (once again) of the smell of industry bodies' lobbying.
It's so obvious they're doing it, it's not even funny any more, and I find
it quite offensive that they chose to use an otherwise legitimate,
informative annual publication to once again flog the dead horse of piracy.
But that's another discussion for another list... ;)

-
Sent via the backstage.bbc.co.uk discussion group.  To unsubscribe, please 
visit http://backstage.bbc.co.uk/archives/2005/01/mailing_list.html.  
Unofficial list archive: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/

Reply via email to