On Mon, 2009-02-09 at 23:15 +0000, Christopher Woods wrote: > different in its model, aiming itself as it does as a social enterprise for > the voluntary and educational sectors. How many schools do you serve in > your > locality? (just curious...) Your model obviously works exceptionally well > for what you do, but I wonder how big your client base is versus how big it > could potentially be if you supported every school in the area - you could > get very big, very fast, or the ground could open up for competition and > aside from lower costs to the end users, there might be an even greater > disparity in levels of support or the kinds of solutions delivered.
As I said in the previous e-mail, school support doesn't scale well. We work through schools to reach families on the wrong side of the digital divide, and also to work with local community organisations, but don't bother offering IT support to the education market - it simply isn't worth it :-/ > > The model of maintaining individually-installed apps over > > several discrete PCs was all very well in the 80s, and > > possibly the 90s, but how long before schools catch up with > > the rest of the world. PCs in schools are mandated to teach > > curriculum areas - this can easily be delivered through 500 - > > 600 web apps. The whole curriculum. A small investment from > > government (less than 1% of the UK's annual school IT spend) > > would get all of these apps written. Released under the GNU > > GPL, they would be tweaked and improved by thousands of > > teachers and students. > > > > Given web apps, designed to work with standards-compliant > > browsers, it becomes irrelevant which platform is used to > > view them, save on grounds of cost and maintainability. The > > obvious choice then is LTSP. > > > Personal opinion: 95% of web apps just don't cut it. If you're talking > about I'm suggesting 500 or 600 wholly new web apps, designed to cover the whole curriculum. A framework would be specified, and commissions given to *UK* developers - including bids from schools. Of course the EU won't let us do it, but there's probably a creative way to frame the tender process. After all, other countries manage. > If I was a teacher I would hate it hate it hate it > if I couldn't teach a class because the main host server was bogged down > with too many intensive tasks, or it fell over or lagged out or needed > to be failed over for some reason. Look at some real world LTSP in schools. Skegness http://schoolforge.org.uk/index.php/Skegness_Grammar have multiple application servers, and seem to have experienced zero downtime so far. > to be desired. If I was speccing a school's IT, I don't think thin clients > would get much way past the first round of planning unless some incredibly > well-designed thin client solutions were brought to my attention (and then > you're talking equivalent prices for thin clients as you would for regular > MiniATX desktops). As has been pointed out elsewhere in the thread, thin clients have a long life (average 8 to 9 years). A point used by Sun in its sales - and the result can be seen in at least one high street bank, and many other large businesses. > I'm still personally very sceptical of thin client solutions, I don't think > their capabilities ar sufficient to satisfy all the potential uses for > educational machines. Music and video editing obviously need their own high-power PCs. > And I wouldn't like to have all that total reliance on > just a handful of extremely powerful servers; it's bad enough when the > Internet proxy server goes down or the network drive can't be accessed > because the Active Directory is having a fit, but to have a classful of > children sitting in front of dumb terminals when the primary host server > for that classroom's client machines goes down? Wuh oh. Last year Salford University moved its School of Computing to thin client - it's saved them no end of problems. Single-point-of-failure risks are easily addressed, but 100s of individual machines will always be a pain :-( In many (most?) of the school labs that I have visited, half of the (Windows) PCs are not working properly - e.g. CD tray will not open - due to creative play from the students (e.g. constantly opening and closing the tray). A malfunctioning PC is an expensive piece of junk. A broken thin client at Skegness Grammar goes in the recycling, and a new one comes out of the cupboard: 30 seconds later it's up and running. > There must be > some reason other than bloody-mindedness that makes schools keep on going > for full-PC solutions time after time though... When you don't know enough to make a purchasing decision, you just buy what everyone else does. Going any other way takes a brave Head Teacher, and Heads have enough on their plates. > I do aim to do more work in > the educational sector as my own business gets going in the next few years, > and I want to offer all kinds of viable solutions as long as they work well > for everybody. Do you really think that setups like the LTSP are as > competitive as regular networks of fairly powerful x86 machines and central > file/print/etc servers for secondary school environments? (not being > sarkies here, genuinely interested to know your thoughts and prepared to do > a lot of reading if you have suggested starting points). Go and visit Skegness, and talk to Garry. :-) > Wrt to government-funded FOSS development for education: unfortunately I > have even less faith in UK.gov to sensibly sort out this kind of project > than the faith I would have in the private sector accomplishing this; BSF is stalling, the Tories have promised to cap IT projects at 100,000. No-one expects any change from the current government, and most (of us) are sadly too skeptical to do more than watch and wait. :-/ > And given the mad state of affairs we're in today, might not the > Competition > Commission declare that UK.gov pouring all this taxpayer money into > developing applications for schools to be horribly anti-competitive as it's > undercutting the commercial market? The private sector would carry out the work. There are enough civil servants - especially in RBS and Northern Rock - without moving programming into Whitehall ;-) - Richard - Sent via the backstage.bbc.co.uk discussion group. To unsubscribe, please visit http://backstage.bbc.co.uk/archives/2005/01/mailing_list.html. Unofficial list archive: http://www.mail-archive.com/[email protected]/

