The Beeb and commerce do not mix well even though the Beeb has a massive
talent pool. The connundrum is about rights to the creative material the
beeb develops and how to keep talent happy. People are always going to share
exciting media content no matter what. The BBC has a massive mindshare
internationally, I have lived abroad so I should know.
I fully support the BBC as a public service, but I also support its efforts
to self sustain with BBC Worldwide, BBC America, BBC DVD and their
investment in EUK with Woolies (which was one of the only divisions of
Woolies which consistently turned a profit). As long as PSB funding is not
cross-subsidising the commercial arms of the BBC, that's fine. The public
funding has to remain in order for the BBC to focus on delivering, as
opposed to have to focus on scrabbling around for money like others. I
understand that divisons of the BBC were strongly instructed to become
commercial in nature by the Powers That Be, and as long as that check and
balance keeps an eye on elements of the Beeb that may not be as 'lean' as
others, in order to make sure they don't just become money sponges, I'm
happy with that too. If they can generate enough profit to keep them
investing in new content and just tick over nicely without requiring support
or increased scrutiny from the rest of the BBC, that's entirely desirable.
The BBC cannot be a public service while pursuing profit. My limited
knowledge suggests that the BBC should nurture and promote talent then allow
the creative minds to go commercial.
Unfortunately I think that time has been forced out of existence... People
want ROI, ROI, ROI! now more than ever. That, and I think the gestation
period for comedy in particular is far shorter than it should be. Most of
the comedy that's been 'nurtured' to fruition in the past few years that you
see on BBC Three is a bit mediocre at best, with glimmers of brilliance
shining through the average remainder. The best comedy shows, most of which
have been around for at least a decade, are still found on BBC Two and Radio
4 (Act Your Age, on R4 every Thursday evening, is a great show). The
'straight to BBC Three' material I usually avoid unless it's personally
recommended by somebody. It's suffering because the Beeb's being squeezed
from all sides and its long history of being a uniquely-positioned, 'slow
burn' broadcaster is being pushed into the verges by those who would see it
commercialised. This problem has, I believe, been one of the main causes of
an underfunding in comedy, bringing it slowly from the radio (where I think
a lot of good comedians find their footing) to the TV.
But that aside, what I expect from the PSB arm of the BBC is an innovating,
boundary-pushing service which covers all areas of media, be it simulcast,
multicast or unicast. I appreciate and support the important role that the
BBC's R&D department plays in the further development of technologies
related to broadcast and broadcast media, plus all the other areas of
technology it benefits. (Whilst R&D is arguably a money sponge, the BBC R&D
department's history and subsequent benefits to everybody should be taken
into account here - R&D is possibly one of the only exceptions when
classifying which departments are 'money pits').
I'm 23, so that puts me on the edge of the Y Generation (those who've always
had technology around them as they've grown up). I know that trad TV and
radio in its current form is quite probably going to be long gone by the
time I'm 40, it will still exist as a service in the same way you can turn
on BBC Two in the evening and 'veg out', but it will be delivered entirely
differently. I think I am willing to see the BBC invest more and more of its
funding into emerging tech far more than, say, the generation prior to mine,
who still embrace FM broadcasting, UHF television and analogue telephone
service more than multicast streaming radio, H.264 DVB-S2 satellite
broadcasts and VoIP telecoms. Unfortunately, it is the generation before me
who still hold the purse strings and whose interests they wish to see borne
out in the behaviour of PSBs, but this will increasingly change as Gen Y
comes into power and decides that no, they'd rather enjoy their
entertainment in the manners to which they are suited.
I am happy for my licence fee to fund the BBC's worthwhile online services,
because I know that is the way the majority of TV and radio will eventually
be consumed and in the short-term I am a full adopter of all these
technologies, provided they are cost-effective and provide me with a
satisfactory consumer experience. (NB that this excludes nearly all forms of
DRM and compromises on quality in all its guises, but this is not purely due
to rightsholders, there are a number of compromises currently in place due
to the immaturity of the Internet, delivery networks etc etc.) I am happy
that iPlayer and its other broadcasters' clones exist, however my tolerance
of the current situation is contingent on it being the first step in the
further development of official online outlets for British TV to a point
where it is a streamlined, wholly satisfactory experience for me.
I am dissatisfied that the Competition Commission regards Kangaroo as being
anti-competitive. Was I consulted by the Competition Commission about
whether I regarded Kangaroo as A Good Thing for me or not? Nope. So, by
having several broadcasters come and offer their content through a
standardised platform which would be available across several technological
platforms... That is anti-competitive? No, that is pro-consumer. I loathe
the inadequate state of play we are in currently, yet all the regulatory
bodies suggest that this is the preferred condition. What's going on with
that? I've seen some of the arguments against Kangaroo (difficulty for other
providers in obtaining content through Kangaroo to offer customers,
unwillingness perhaps on the behalf of Kangaroo to offer content to
particular organisations etc) - but Kangaroo will be offering content direct
from a range of partners, if a partner wants to offer content in other ways
then they are quite entitled to as well as joining Kangaroo. Kangaroo is not
another iTunes, there is no vendor-specific lock in (and I hope there won't
be in terms of DRM or required software either). However, from what I
understand Kangaroo would be offering content through platforms on which it
is far harder to provide a consistent experience (STBs, etc) so in this
regard their experience and their consolidated platform would be invaluable
to promote on-demand, micropayment-based PPV and timeshift viewing. A
perfect complementary service to Freesat, too...
I have no problem with Kangaroo becoming a de facto provider and gateway for
quality content given its pedigree and the trust I already have in the
potential purveyors, however this is only as long as they are in turn fair
to both the consumers and the content providers (and they are willing to
freely licence material for rebroadcast to other providers, e.g. Virgin
Media's own brand on-demand service). I've always anticipated Kangaroo to be
a wholesale provider direct to consumers though, I don't want it to become
just another 'behind the scenes' framework and provider which is rebranded
by broadcasters or platform providers because that sucks. Sky can keep their
lame duck, antiquated walled garden approach to themselves, but I'd still be
quite happy to see their stuff also land on the Kangaroo platform (Sky Three
content, etc).
If the CC is so concerned, the BBC should eventually spin off Kangaroo into
a commercial entity just like Worldwide, Entertainment and their overseas
channels - sharing the brand and the reputation - but it needs to be an
in-house venture initially to be given the support and investment, both
financial and experience, to succeed in a decidedly bizarre marketplace.