And sure enough, Martin hits the nail on the head.  (And, for the benefit of
Dave, no, he's not "confusing an ethical position with a religious one" -
you obviously missed the bit that says "with a few word changes".  Perhaps
parts of your monitor are obscured with froth?)

RIch.


On 12/30/07, Dave Crossland <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
>
> On 29/12/2007, Martin Belam <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> > > An excellent quote which I will endeavour to use in 2008 every time
> > > the zealots start drowning out the conversation.
> >
> > though I suspect you will be met with similar content to almost the
> > first reaction to that article:
> >
> > "It's sad to see that Linus Torvalds, one of the leading figures in
> > the Free Software movement, doesn't really care for freedom."
>
> Here's the full comment:
>
> "It's sad to see that Linus Torvalds, one of the leading figures in
> the Free Software movement, doesn't really care for freedom. And it's
> even sadder that he resorts to insults, saying that those who *do*
> care about freedom are "frothing-at-the-mouth".
>
> I think it's also dishonest for Linus to see only the people who like
> to have control over their computers as ideological. Linus' own view
> that users should *not* have control over their computers is just as
> ideological, and Linus is actively pushing his own ideology on other
> people.
>
> Personally I disagree with Linus. I find that freedom means control
> over your own computer and I believe that all computer users have a
> right to be free and in control."
>
> I think the point about "proprietary restrictions are conscionable if
> the software has some convenient feature" being an ideology that
> Torvalds pushes is interesting.
>
> > > it's also applicable, with a few word changes, to religion too
>
> Are you confusing an ethical position with a religious one?
>
> --
>

Reply via email to