>
>
> > No.  Banging on and on and on and on about the same tired, laboured
> point is
> > wrong - and simply blindly quoting Richard Stallman doesn't make it any
> more
> > likely to have people agree with your narrow viewpoint.  You are Dave
> > Crossland in a different hat, and I claim my five pounds.
>
> This is where our opinions diverge.


Ah, so continually banging on and on about the same laboured point is OK is
it?


>
> I, obviously, have some strong view points on freedom and politics. I
> join /discussion/ groups so that I can /discuss/ the issues that
> interest me.


Yes, I see that.  Please note the difference between "discussion" and
"repeatedly banging on".


>
> When a /discussion/ starts that involves freedom or politics I find
> that I like to join in the /discussion/ by weighing in with my
> opinion. That, after all, is the point of a /discussion/ list.


Fine, but note that "weighing in with" is not neccessarily a synonym for
"repeatedly banging on about".

"Discussing" is a two way process.  Standing on a soapbox and shouting
"LISTEN TO ME!" is not.  (There's something wrong with your keyboard BTW -
it's putting quote marks out as slashes)


>
> I only /discuss/ things that interest me when there is direct
> relevance to the /discussion/ at hand. If a newbie asks "how can I get
> foo driver to work with linux" you won't find me correcting his use of
> the word "linux" to include "gnu" but you will find me correcting
> someone who says "tescos should sell and market linux pcs." See the
> difference?


Yes.  How is this relevant?


>
> When someone accuses me of "banging on" about something really they
> are saying "I have heard your opinion before, don't like it and can't
> be bothered discussing it."


No.  They're saying "You've made exactly that point before, there's no need
to keep repeating it - it's not going to get any more valid or true the
ninth time you make it, and you're certainly not going to convince anyone to
change their minds.  You're far more likely to alienate people."


>
> To which I have two suggestions:
>
>  1) Leave the /discussion/ list you're on.
>  2) Move to the next message, trash the message and move on.
>  3) Filter all email with "freedom" in the body into /dev/null and be
> done with it.


That's three.  Like the Spanish Inquisition this...

I have a suggestion too.  Why not limit making the exact same point to, ooh,
three times per day, per discussion list?  That way it comes across less
like bullying.


>
> Stop throwing you're weight around because you can't be bothered
> /discussing/ something on a /discussion/ list.


I hope you're not suggesting I have any weight to throw around.  I just find
bullies, extremists and zealots of any descripton intensely annoying,
especially in what's generally a friendly environment.

Rich.

Reply via email to