Rawat, You made a lot of sense here. I agree with what you said.
Taimur, you are free to choose what you like and not like, but I honestly feel that if you cannot like an album like D6 or Raavan, your chances of being happy with future ARR albums will be quite low. I am glad I am not in your position. Also, I never mentioned as a rule that you only have to choose songs from my list. I only listed the songs that touched me. Why didn't you choose songs that touched you independent of my list? Why did you want to make it a point to show that you are so critical of ARR's Hindi works that you only listed one song in the last 5 years that you enjoyed? But, later, you mentioned Chan Chan and Shyam that you liked from Water. Any more that you "forgot" to mention? So, what is it man? --- In [email protected], V S Rawat <vsra...@...> wrote: > > On 8/29/2010 2:50 AM India Time, _Taimur Nadeem_ wrote: > > > well i liked three songs from water , the best being Ayo re sakhi than > > sham rang and than bangari marori. the others songs just not there. > > I am dumbfounded that anyone can NOT like Piya Ho. ARR had put such a > unique feeling in that song, so touching, so genuine that even even > ARR has not used in any of his other 1000+ songs. nearest was probably > Manchandre but that too sounds too farmaishi show off when compared > with Piya Ho. > > > and i choose those three from AJ's list. otherwise i liked many in tamil > > but very little in hindi. > > His list has many tamil songs also, but it seems you didn't like those > particular ones and might have liked others. > > I wudn't be much help in discussion on tamil songs, but I think it > will help u regain confidence in ARR if you put efforts to make his > list of tamil songs that you liked. You mentioned total three, you > could have off hand recalled 5-10 more at least that you liked. > > I personally felt offended for a moment that you just mentioned 3 > songs that you liked. I can mention many more than "three" songs of > Anu Malik, Nadeem Sharavan, Anand Milind, SEL, Vishal1, Vishal2, and > most of the MDs that I like. > > I feel like saying that if you can't even like 1 song a year from ARR, > you should rethink why you remain a fan of him? You should move on to > other MDs that you like. It is OK. It happens that we stop clicking > with someone and start clicking with other ones. We should not let our > old habit stagnate us without pleasure. After all that is how, I mean > by moving on from other previous MDs to ARR, we had come to become fan > of ARR in the first place. > > Another aspect is that ARR's fan based likes, loves, adores D6, Ravan > type of music. This was vintage ARR with innovations. So, if you don't > like even a single song in these, it will be very unprobable that ARR > will ever give an album for your genres of liking. > > I am also dumbfounded that these time when ARR is at the peak of his > worldwide fame only due to his sustained efforts, you are dissatisfied > so much with him. > > > regards, > > taimur > > Enjoy. > > Rawat > > > > > > > --- On *Sat, 8/28/10, V S Rawat /<vsra...@...>/* wrote: > > > > > > From: V S Rawat <vsra...@...> > > Subject: Re: [arr] ARR songs that have reached the deepest since 2005 > > To: [email protected] > > Date: Saturday, August 28, 2010, 3:13 AM > > > > On 8/28/2010 1:02 AM India Time, _Taimur Nadeem_ wrote: > > > > > here is mine AJ from your list , > > > Omana penne > > > bangari marori > > > > Just curious. > > > > While you mention Water, I want to confirm that you liked Bangari > > marori more than Piya Rey from this album. Right? > > > > > mausam n escape > > > REGARDS, > > > taimur > > > > Rawat >
