When did we witness "making" of ARR? Didn't we find ARR in his very first release, exactly the way he is, with all the path-breaking innovations, different style, uniqueness, novel sounds.
It doesn't mean that ARR has "not" improved since roja. of course he has, but he has followed a "signature" that we fans instantly recognize and we instantly notice missing in pappu. I mean to say, ARR didn't get "made" by hit and trial and error by 20 films. I think ARR had some gift by Higher Power and he confidently used that skill and has been using always using. I have no problem if Amit Trivedi or vishal or even pritam gives good music and we get a variety. I am increasingly liking more and more songs of pritam. I still like Nadeem Shravan's pardesi jana nahi, and Anu Malik's sandeshe aate hain. Still, while piyush mishra clicked with me by heart in his first album gulal, Amit Trivedi had not yet clicked with me in any of his songs. I have heard and seen DevD and Udaan and I don't remember even a single song of Udaan, nor felt anything great happening when I saw the songs on the screen. That might be my personal liking. Good if he evolves. Though I wouldn't count on it. I don't personally think that Amit has any element of ARR. The clue is "ARR didn't get [made]. ARR is visiting this planet with that skill already ingrained in him by Almighty's personal handiwork." -- Rawat On 7/22/2010 9:11 PM India Time, _Aditya Pai_ wrote: > *Amit Trivedi* is one music director who is proving himself to be one of > the versatile music directors in the film industry. First it was *Dev D > *then a song *Iktara* from* Wake Up Sid *now with *Aisha *and *Udaan* he > has surprised me a lot. His songs has uniqueness just like *A.R.Rahman* > who keeps on experimenting. *Amit Trivedi's *song may not be very catchy > at first listen but you will start liking it after you watch the movie. > For example:* Dev D *and *Udaan* which were not very impressive at first > hearing but I started liking it after I watched the movie.... *Aisha *is > another album which too has interesting songs like *Gal Mitthi Mitthi > Bol....* > * > * > So *Amit Trivedi* is trying to catch up with the legends like > *A.R.Rahman* & *S-E-L.* Though it is very hard for him and also may take > some time to match up with these legends but still it is possible. That > will happen if he continues to deliver some more hit songs in future. > >
