On 11/25/2008 1:45 AM India Time, _my_arr_ wrote: > Here is one simple question for those who are > comparing hindi Ghajini to Tamil version.. Do you > think the Tamil tracks can fulfill the needs of the > hindi ghajini movie and the audience if the original > songs are dubbed or if HJ is requested to compose for > Hindi Ghajini?
I think Yes. Guys, HJ is a good MD, he has given good music in earlier hindi films, why should we doubt that he wouldn't have come up with a music appropriate for hindi audience also? Of course, he is no ARR. :0) ARR is so great that comparing HJ with ARR, I think, demeans ARR. ARR is a father figure in music now, HJ is sort of a newbie, though a promising one. > I bet it's not gonna happen... > > Am happy that more people are realizing the magic of > Ghajini songs.. Keep on listening and reward your ears > and souls.. > > my_arr Though, I have to concede that I have seen Hindi Aparichit (Anniyan's dub) with music by HJ and it's songs, especially that "Kumari" in the gardens/ fields sound so much sound-indian-ish in music/ dress/ settings, that it didn't suit hindi film at all. Frankly, probably it was the best romantic song of the tamil film, but it appeared an irritating comedy in hindi film. But then, it was a dubbed music, not "remade" by HJ himself. I still think that if HJ was given chance to remake the music, he would have come up with appropriate music for hindi audience, and shankar would have come up with appropriate visuals. -- rawat
