I agree with you rivjot ... good thinking!
--- On Sat, 9/27/08, rivjot <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
From: rivjot <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
Subject: [arr] Re: ARR's another hard work wasted in sakkarakatii
To: [email protected]
Date: Saturday, September 27, 2008, 5:24 AM
Sath,
I agree with you only upto some extent here. Obviously, it hurts when
movie doesnt do well on box office. Projects that Rahman takes, music
is obviously the positive point of the project, but music gets even
higher acclaim and gets on better sales if movie is appreciated. Any
movie that doesnt do well, music doesnt get sold as much as it should
have been.
In Rahman's case, music is one giant PART of the project. Rahman's
music stands out itself. Looking at the list that you posted. SOK,
Uyire (Dil Se) - Rahman won filmfare award for best music director for
them even though movie didnt do well. hence, movie's performance
effects partially in this case. Others movies that you listed there,
people know them from Rahman's music, not from actor's performance.
Consequently, I would not say "ARR's hard work is wasted" if movie
doesnt do well; his hard work will never be wasted as long as he got
supporters/fans like you guys :)
--- In arrahmanfans@ yahoogroups. com, "sath.murthy" <sath.murthy@ ...>
wrote:
>
> This has been the nth time that ARR's brilliant score has been wasted by
> the directors. i am talking about the sweet cube here....
> How many times will this happen? ARR spends so much time in creating
> such wonderful music and songs, but the movies doesn't match upto it.
> ARR should be careful in choosing the movies hereafter, i personally
> think he should give much priority to the storyline than the big names
> and producers. I guess Harris has few failures compared to ARR so far
> because of that.
> Each and every review i read so far about the sakarakatti has been bad,
> they all agree that only good thing in that movie is the music and BGM.
> I couldnt control my disappointment when i read the reviews of the sweet
> cube. The movie has been hyped up so much but fell flat on its first
> show.
> The reviews also say that kadalil vilunthen is far better than SK. Now
> Nakka Mukka will overtake Taxi Taxi and Marudhanni just because of their
> respective storylines.
>
> Can you guys please throw in some movies name that bombed at the box
> office even though they had beautiful music by ARR.
> I remember the following:
> Kangalal Kaithu Sei
> Kadhal Virus
> Boys (to an extent)
> ATM
> Baba
> Duet
> E20U18
> En Swasa kaatre
> SOK
> Paarthale Paravasam
> Rhythm
> Tajmahal
> Udhaya
> Uyire
>
> If you see the above list, it even includes the big stalwarts like
> Maniratnam, Shankar, Kathir, Bharathiraja. ....
> I have mentioned only the tamil movies, there is a big list in HINDI
> too. Please throw in some names that matches the above category.
>
> Whenever ARR music release i am so happy and when i come to know that
> film bombed at the BO because of the story or screenplay, it makes me so
> sick.
> I couldnt find proper words to let out my disappointment.
>
> Thanks
> Sath
>
