Also maybe cuz Gulzar penned both bidi jalayale and mayya mayya.
On 6/1/08, V S Rawat <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > On 6/1/2008 9:23 AM India Time, _kishore parayath_ wrote: > > > Pls dont mention COPYCATS VISHAL-SEKHAR in this Holy Community...... > > They are disgusting..shameless creatures.... Whereas the name > > Shankar-ehsaan-loy is very much deserving to be mentioned in this > > community...They are good, genuine and committed composers...... > > > > k. done. > > I liked 2-3 songs of Om Shanti Om but have not bothered to know much > about Vishal-Sekhar so I didn't even know that they have copied that music. > > SEL are indeed good in the new breed, but consistentcy and popularity is > not there with them. A R Rahman had become a household name for Hindi > music in some 3-4 years (Roza, Humse hai muqabla, Bombay, Rangeela), but > SEL is now in some 10th year and has given some 20 films and some are > indeed good, but if they has not become a household name, I think it is > because their rate of improvement and innovation are quite slow. They > should give more Dil Chahta hai stuff which has a soul soothing > freshness. And while we are at DCH, let me mention that though I don't > like Javed's lyrics much, still I smile everytime I listen to or > remember his line from the film "Ishq ke Ghaat jo utartey hain." What a > naughty line. Those who don't know, there is a hindi phrase, sort of > idiom, "Maut ke ghaat utarna", so he twisted a word and put "Ishq" at > the level of "maut" which migles so well in the love-is-stupidity > persona of Aamir in this film. He should give more such things compared > to the prose lectures he penned for Ye Taara, Wo Taara of Swades. > > -- > Still, when Mahendra Kapoor speaks about today's music being not good, > he is basically wrong because even the copycats are also ending up > giving hummable music because they copy from the music that was good and > popular in original so the copy also becomes good. e.g. Anu Malik ended > up giving good music in Gentleman stealing note by note from our man. > > -- > Rawat > > >
