Its not the release date thats considered for National Awards. Its based on censoring date. Thats why even non-released films get National Awards. oiow, 2005 NA is for films censored between Jan 1 2005 and Dec 31 2005.
I too agree there are many more deserving candidates for male playback singer than Naresh for Roobaro. (Just considering RDB alone, my award would go to ARR for Khalbali:-) ). I am pretty sure it would have been Shringaram and RDB in last round for Best Music. I think the award was given to Naresh as the jury wanted to give some award to RDB in music section. I can give many examples similar to this from past. (Best supp actor award to Prakash Raj for Iruvar comes to mind instantly) Thanks, Vinod --- In [email protected], "John jeevinth" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > DUde no 1 is debatin out here v r just not happy wit ARR not gettin de award > and no 1 is abusin SHRI.LALGUDI ... and v r not goin to Discuss about him,, > and v dont want any1 to do dat.. > As fans of ARR. v really xpected him to get de National for RDB it deserved. > it..and v was RDB included in 2005 awards list..it was released in 2006 > jan... :x > > On 8/8/07, Ranojoy <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > Naresh Iyer's wasn't the best male performance IMHO. Shafqat Amanat > > Ali Khan was by far the most impressive performer in Mitwa, followed > > by Zubeen in Ya Ali (pardoning the fact that it's copied).. There > > were several performances that ranked above Roobaroo.. > > Roobaroo isn't too difficult of a song to sing. > > Would like to hear others' opinions on this, without bias, since > > it's not really directly A R R-related. > > > > --- In [email protected] <arrahmanfans% 40yahoogroups.com>, > > Sarathy S <saarathysrini@> > > wrote: > > > > > > > > > I HUMBLY REQUEST THE ORGANISER OF THIS GROUP NOT TO ALLOW ANY > > POSTS DEGRADING SRINGARAM MUSIC DIRECTOR.... THANKS FOR THE > > SAME........ IF NOT SOME OF RAHMAN FANS, RAHMAN KNOWS ABOUT HIM & I > > SALUTE BOTH RAHMAN & SHRI.LALGUDI FOR THEIR ACHIEVEMENTS IN > > MUSIC.... :-) AND DEAR SANDEEP, > > > > > > SORRY TO INTERFERE...... REQUEST ARR FANS THOSE WHO DO NOT KNOW > > ABOUT THIS LIVING LEGEND SHRI LALGUDI....... KINDLY NEED NOT ENTER > > INTO DEBATE ABOUT HIS MUSIC ABILITY AS IT IS TOTALLY A DIFFERENT > > GENRE PERSON & VERY VERY ELDERLY RESPECTED & REGARDED AS PITHAAMAA > > OF VIOLIN IN SOUTH WHO GOT AN OFFER TO DO MUSIC AS AN HONOUR..... > > BEING A NATIONAL AWARD OUR GOVERNMENT CONSIDER THIS AS ITS DUTY TO > > HONOUR THIS LEGEND........ HE WON NO. OF AWARDS, ACCOLADES IN > > REGIONAL, NATIONAL & INTERNATIONAL LEVEL TO HIS CREDIT RIGHT FROM > > HIS VERY YOUNG AGE LIKE RAHMAN BUT IN CLASSICAL MUSIC AS A > > VIOLINIST....... RAHMAN HIMSELF WILL NOT ALLOW SUCH COMMENTS AT > > THESE LEGENDS......... OR TO SAY IF > > > > > > LATA MANGESHKARJI'S NAME ALSO THERE WITH ANOTHER CURRENT FAMOUS > > FEMALE PLAYBACK SINGER IN HINDI FILM SINGER AWARDS.... NATURALLY > > THEY WILL SELECT LATAJI FOR HER SENIORITY & ACHIEVEMENTS JUST TO > > HONOUR HER THOUGH SHE MAY NOT PERFORM WELL THAT PARTICULAR SONG > > CHOSEN FOR AWARD DUE TO HER AGE NOW....... THIS IS LIKE THAT ONLY > > AND TO BEST SAY IT IS AS EQUAL TO COMMENT ABOUT OUR EX-PRESIDENT > > SHRI.A.P.J.ABDUL KALAM WITHOUT KNOWING HIM BETTER INTERESTINGLY WHO > > IS ALSO A GREAT VEENA PLAYER IN CARNATIC MUSIC..... > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Sandeep Mody <sandeepmodysrm@> wrote: > > > > > > did anybody listen "SRINGARAM" movie songs??? Is it > > worth giving this award commpare to RDB?? > > > > > > On 8/7/07, PRATAP KRISHNAN < pratap_elensar@> > > wrote: What????? What a dissapointment?! I was so > > confident its for ARR! Better luck nx time Rahman. > > > > > > > > > vinodraju2k < rajv_2k@> wrote: > > > http://pib.nic.in/archieve/others/2007/aug07/53rd_nfa-2005.pdf > > > > > > 15. BEST MALE PLAYBACK SINGER > > > NARESH IYER > > > RAJAT KAMAL AND A CASH PRIZE OF RS. 10,000/- TO > > > MALE PLAYBACK SINGER NARESH IYER > > > > > > THE AWARD FOR THE BEST MALE PLAYBACK SINGER OF 2005 IS GIVEN TO > > > NARESH IYER IN RANG DE BASANTI, FOR HIS MELODIOUS RENDERING OF A > > > LILTING SONG " ROO BA ROO" THAT ADDS EXUBERENCE TO THE FILM. > > > > > > 16. BEST FEMALE PLAYBACK SINGER > > > SHREYA GHOSHAL > > > RAJAT KAMAL AND A CASH PRIZE OF RS. 10,000/- TO > > > FEMALE PLAYBACK SINGER SHREYA GHOSHAL > > > > > > THE AWARD FOR THE BEST FEMALE PLAYBACK SINGER OF 2005 IS GIVEN TO > > > SHREYA GHOSHAL IN THE HINDI FILM PAHELI FOR HER EVOCATIVE > > > RENDITION OF A SONG " APNE AANSOO PEENE KE LIYE" THAT TREADS THE > > > FINE BALANCE BETWEEN THE CLASSCIAL AND POPULAR GENRE OF HINDI FILM > > > MUSIC. > > > > > > 23. BEST MUSIC DIRECTION > > > LALGUDI JAYARAMAN FOR SRINGARAM (TAMIL) > > > RAJAT KAMAL AND A CASH PRIZE OF RS. 10,000/- TO > > > MUSIC DIRECTORS (SONGS AND BACKGROUND MUSIC SCORE) > > > LALGUDI JAYARAMAN > > > > > > THE AWARD FOR THE BEST MUSIC DIRECTION OF 2005 IS GIVEN TO > > > LALGUDI JAYARAMAN FOR THE TAMIL FILM SRINGARAM FOR BRINGING > > > ALIVE AN ERA OF GREAT MUSICAL AND DANCE TRADITION THROUGH THE DEFT > > > USE OF INDIAN MUSICAL INSTRUMENTS. > > > > > > 24. BEST LYRICS > > > BARGURU RAMCHANDRAPPA > > > RAJAT KAMAL AND A CASH PRIZE OF RS. 10,000/- TO > > > LYRICIST BARGURU RAMCHANDRAPPA > > > > > > THE AWARD FOR THE BEST LYRICS OF 2005 IS GIVEN TO BARGURU > > > RAMCHANDRAPPA FOR THE LYRIC "BARUTHE VE NAV BARUTHE VE" IN THE > > > KANNADA FILM THAAYI WHICH HEIGHTENED THE EFFECT OF THE ENTIRE FILM. > > > > > > -Vinod > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > --------------------------------- > > > Luggage? GPS? Comic books? > > > Check out fitting gifts for grads at Yahoo! Search. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > Trusting in God never makes the mountain smaller, it just makes > > the climbing easier. I never ask Him for the lighter load, but only > > for the stronger back. > > > > > > when goin is very tough , tough get goin... > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > --------------------------------- > > > Moody friends. Drama queens. Your life? Nope! - their life, your > > story. > > > Play Sims Stories at Yahoo! Games. > > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > -John >
