On Mon, 2026-04-13 at 11:18 +0900, Nilrem via agora-discussion wrote: > On 4/13/26 6:07 AM, Edward Murphy via agora-discussion wrote: > > Proto-Proposal: Pig Pen > > (AI = whatever) > > > > Create a rule titled <something> with Power <1.7? 2?> and this text: > > > > <X> is a player switch with values <Y> (default) and <Z>. > > > > A player CAN flip eir <X> from <Y> to <Z> by announcement. > > > > A player CAN flip eir <X> from <Z> to <Y> if e has been <Z> for > > least three months. > > > > If a <Z> player commits an infraction, all players SHOULD note it > > (if not already noted), and the Investigator SHOULD assign as > > large a penalty as possible when investigating it. > > > > [An attempt to make Referee more interesting without generating too many > > bad feelings: the law only throws the book at you if you volunteered > > for it. Optionally add some incentive, e.g. make this a third way to > > gain a White Ribbon.] > > > > What do we think about giving <Z> players +1 voting strength? I'm not > sure if that would be too powerful.
This seems reasonable to me (especially as the extra blots would tend to cancel it out). I think that, because this rule only applies SHOULDs, it could reasonably exist at power 1 (flipping the switch by scam would not be useful because it would be a reason to intentionally violate a SHOULD, which is something you can do if you have a good reason). -- ais523 Referee
