On Sun, 2024-07-21 at 18:59 -0500, secretsnail wrote:
> ID: 9145
> Title: Pragmatic quarters
> Adoption Index: 2.0
> Author: Murphy
> Co-authors: Mischief
> 
> 
> Amend Rule 2555 (Blots) by replacing this text:
> 
>        At the beginning of each quarter, half (rounded down) of each
>        fugitive's blots are destroyed.
> 
> with this text:
> 
>        Once a quarter, the Referee CAN and SHALL publish a Notice of
>        Clemency, upon which half (rounded down) of each fugitive's blots
>        are destroyed.

This doesn't actually provide a mechanism for the Referee to do so
(likewise with the other similar obligations in this proposal) – it
just states that it's possible. (In particular, it gives no indication
of what a Notice of Clemency is – just labelling a message as one
probably wouldn't be enough, because the rules don't state that a
message labelled as a Notice of Clemency actually *is* a Notice of
Clemency.) What's our precedent on how to deal with this sort of
obligation?

-- 
ais523

Reply via email to