On Sun, 2023-05-07 at 17:24 -0700, Forest Sweeney via agora-discussion wrote: > Title: Did you try turning it off and on?
Strongly AGAINST this, it would allow players to easily revoke any asset defined at power 1 from everybody at once via disabling the rule defining it. That would, in effect, make it impossible to have a workable economy unless we went around specifically securing all the economic rules against this. As a simple example, Commune's assets are backed by a Power=1 rule, so this would allow anyone to, with notice, reset the entire tournament. That would make gameplay there effectively impossible. It might also possible be possible to break the proposal system at power 1, by causing the Assessor to no longer be an office (thus making it so that there's nobody who CAN resolve proposals, and nobody can deputise either). I'm not sure that works because there's a power-3 "defaulting" in rule 208 which may make it possible for the Promotor to resolve Agoran Decisions in that case, as a fallback, but I think it might fail due to Cretans. Perhaps we might want to clarify the rules, to make sure. (Note that this would not be an ossification because you could still fix things by RWOing the office, or indeed flipping the switch back again – it's just something I noticed when trying to figure out what implications this proposal would have.) -- ais523
