On 5/7/2022 1:02 PM, nix via agora-business wrote:
> Amend R2138 "The Associate Director of Personnel" by appending:
> 
>      4. For filled offices, the percent of reports that have been
>         published in a timely fashion since either this clause was added
>         to the rules or the last change in officeholder for the office,
>         whichever is more recent.

I agree with moving to something like this in principle, but I think that
the metric needs work.

 - you can clear your name by resigning and re-deputizing for the office;

 - there's no notion of forgiving the past without resigning in this
   manner;

 - as time goes on in an office, each missed report contributes less %, so
   it means the longer you hold the office the less the % matters and the
   less you might care (I have learned this point playing Wordle lol).

Overall this seems opposite of what we'd want a metric to do - which would
be to go lower if you missed a present/recent report, but forgive the more
distant past.  So I'm concerned this incentivizes what we don't want?

-G.

Reply via email to