> In order to determine which of these scenarios occurred, we need to look at
> R105, "Rule Changes". First, we can eliminate scenario 1. While Rule 105
> doesn't specifically lay out what occurs during amendment, we can assume
> that the former text of the rule no longer exists because it is fully
> replaced by the new text. As a result, the old text would not have
> sufficient power to amend a rule, therefore Scenario 1 is not valid.

I just happened across CFJ 3419, which addresses a similar issue and
comes to the same conclusion.

- Falsifian

Reply via email to