On 2/19/2020 9:33 AM, Jason Cobb via agora-discussion wrote: > On 2/19/20 10:20 AM, Kerim Aydin via agora-official wrote: >> The below CFJ is 3810. I assign it to Jason. >> >> status: https://faculty.washington.edu/kerim/nomic/cases/#3810 >> >> =============================== CFJ 3810 =============================== >> >> It is generally POSSIBLE to act on behalf of a zombie to transfer >> karma. >> >> ========================================================================== > > > At [0], G. wrote: > >> I think there was a court case that found that "publishing an X" >> where X is a specific action that the principal CAN do in the rules by >> publishing it (like a Notice of Honour or support/objection) was (in the >> language of R2466) a "performing a specific action within a message" rather >> than simply "sending a message". >> >> I remember disagreeing with the judgement but then we added that specific >> zombie-limitation to R2532 when we did a big negotiated zombie nerf. >> (unfortunately I think the CFJ happened in the database gap between CFJs >> 3585 and 3634, maybe someone else remembers more precisely...). > > > If such a CFJ actually exists, I think the one I'm assigned would be > very easily determined from it. I glanced at all of the Court Gazettes > in the time period within the 3585-3634 gap, and didn't seem anything > that looks relevant, and I also searched the H. Arbitor's archive on > GitHub for the words "publish" and "publishing", and, after glancing at > all of the results, I was unable to find such a CFJ. > > Does anybody have any idea which CFJ G. might be referring to? > > > [0]: > https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-discussion/2019-September/055503.html >
My apologies for not following up to that message. I did a fairly thorough search myself after I wrote that - I remember a discussion and some level of consensus but I couldn't find an actual CFJ. Aris, does this ring any bells, I vaguely remember you saying something similar to your gratuitous arguments for this case, which is what convinced me at the time, but that could be a completely faulty memory along with the phantom cfj. -G.
