On 2/14/20 12:59 PM, Timon Walshe-Grey via agora-business wrote: > *sigh* > > CFJ, barring Falsifian: "Falsifian was awarded a Red Ribbon today." > > Arguments: > > Rule 2438 says: > > Red (R): When a proposal is adopted and changes at least one rule > that, immediately before or after the change, has Power >= 3, its > proposer earns a Red Ribbon. > > i.e., if a proposal does not change a rule, it does not earn its author > a Red Ribbon, even if it has Power >= 3. > > There is some uncertainty about whether Proposal 8308 changed a rule. > Some time ago (can't find the thread), Alexis asserted that it didn't > because it was too vague. > > The Rulekeepor is probably the best person to rule on this (no pun > intended). > > -twg
I'll admit I handled this inconsistently: when the original chambers proposal was adopted, I assumed it worked by adding the list element to the end of the list. Then, when the fix proposal was adopted, I recorded it as amending the rule without changing the text (just to ensure there was a record of it). So, the official Rulekeepor stance right now is ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ . -- Jason Cobb
