My 2 cents: I believe the answer to this is TRUE. I think game custom provides that the Ruleset is the set-of-all-rules. I am not sure what the alternative definition could be. There’s no reason for the Ruleset to be a subset-of-all-rules, and we wouldn’t have any principled way to discern which rules are included in that Ruleset and which aren’t.
If the Ruleset is the set-of-all-rules, then ratifying the Ruleset would “modif[y]” the “gamestate” to what“what it would be if, at the time the [Short Logical Ruleset] was published, the gamestate had been minimally modified to make the ratified [Short Logical Ruleset] as true and accurate as possible.” I think that would imply that the gamestate is modified such that the SLR would truly and accurately represent the set-of-all-rules, with the implication that any rule not in the ratified SLR would cease to exist. > On Sep 28, 2019, at 12:48 PM, Kerim Aydin <ke...@uw.edu> wrote: > > > CFJ: Ratifying the SLR also ratifies the fact that no other > Rules (other than those in the ratified SLR) exist. > > > Caller's Arguments: > > By R1681, the SLR is a format of the ruleset: > > The Short Logical Ruleset (SLR) is a format of the ruleset. > > By R1051, it is also part of the Rulekeepor's Weekly Report: > > The Rulekeepor's Weekly report includes the Short Logical Ruleset. > > In the rules, "the ruleset" is not explicitly defined, but a common > definition would be "the set of all rules". > > So does ratifying the SLR ratify the implication that there are > no other rules (i.e. that the ratified set is complete)? Note that in > some types of reports we explicitly handle/cover missing values, e.g. > in R2162 for switches: > > a public document > > purporting to be this portion of that officer's report is > > self-ratifying, and implies that other instances are at their > > default value. > > We don't have text like that for the SLR/the ruleset. > > If it's useful, here's how Proposal 8175 (adopted 08-May-2019) phrased the > last SLR ratification: > > ID: 8175 > > Title: SLR Ratification > > Adoption index: 3.0 > > Author: Aris > > Co-authors: > > > > > > Ratify the Short Logical Ruleset published on the 24th of February, 2019, > > available here [1]. > > > > [1] https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official > > /2019-February/012797.html >
