You adopted the reasons, but arguably not the judgement. Could you say that you judge it FALSE, just in case?
-Aris On Wed, Feb 13, 2019 at 3:54 PM D. Margaux <dmargaux...@gmail.com> wrote: > > I adopt the below reasons as my final judgment In this CFJ. > > I earn 5 coins and award myself 3 PLA favours for issuing the CFJ. > > Begin forwarded message: > > > From: "D. Margaux" <dmargaux...@gmail.com> > > Date: February 12, 2019 at 8:17:07 PM EST > > To: agora-busin...@agoranomic.org > > Subject: Re: BUS: Registration and Birthday > > > > Welcome! > > > > I assign that CFJ to myself > > > > Under the rule, I believe that a player CAN declare a date to be eir > birthday only “with Agoran Consent,” which is a particular method of taking > actions described in Rule 1728 that requires that you first announce your > intent to perform the action, and give players an opportunity to support or > object to it, and the action is permitted only if more people support than > oppose. So based on that, I think the CFJ is FALSE, and I judge it that way > unless there is something I am missing. > > > >> On Feb 12, 2019, at 7:52 PM, James Cook <jc...@cs.berkeley.edu> wrote: > >> > >> I register. I go by "Falsifian" in online settings, or just my real name > >> "James" if you prefer. > >> > >> My Agoran Birthday is the day beginning at midnight UTC on February 13, > >> 2018. > >> > >> I initiate a CFJ for the statement "It is Falsifian's Agoran Birthday > today > >> (the day beginning at midnight UTC on February 13, 2019).". > >> > >> Here is my argument: > >> > >> 1. I declared earlier in this message that is my Agoran Birthday was one > >> year ago. This is a simple matter of fact that anyone reading this can > >> verify. The rules cannot change this fact. > >> > >> 2. The day I first registered is unknown, because I haven't told anyone. > >> For example, as far as anyone else knows, I might have first registered > a > >> very long time ago under a different name. > >> > >> 3. Rule 2585 says: "As long as the day a player first registered remains > >> unknown, it is considered to be eir Agoran Birthday on the anniversary > of > >> the day e most recently declared as eir Agoran Birthday.". Based on my > two > >> earlier points, then, today is the anniversary of my Agoran Birthday. >
