H. Rulekeepor, some suggested annotations follow. I've chosen things
that might be of historical interest pretty much randomly.

-Aris
---
Rule: 869
CFJ: 3625
Called: 12 Feb 2018
Consent to abide by some of the rules does not suffice for registration.

Rule: 2141
CFJ: 3622
Called: 7 Feb 2018
A statement by the rules that some event occurs, provided without all
information necessary to understand the event, is not sufficient to
cause the event to occur.
(I'd suggest rephrasing this one, I couldn't think of a better way to
word it. You've already annotated the case on R1650, but I believe
that it has broader implications.)

Rule: 2517
CFJ: 3617
Called: 29 Nov 2017
An inextricable (paradoxical, in the case in question) conditional is
not satisfied, and therefore cannot impose an obligation.

Rule: 2141
CFJ: 3580
Called: 21 Oct 2017
The rules can override reality for game purposes.

Rule: 101
CFJ: 3580
Called: 21 Oct 2017
Agora exists platonically, and so can exist without the rest of reality.

Rule: 2152 (not sure of the best place to put this)
CFJ: 3539
Called: 6 Jul 2017
A late obligation can still be fulfilled.

Rule: 2201
CFJ: 3522
Called: 9 Jun 2017
A claim of a self-ratifying document that has been marked as disputed
does not self-ratify.

Rule: 105
CFJ: 3482
Called: 3 May 2017
A rule that has been repealed no longer has a power.

Rule: 478 (R217 might be appropriate instead, because that seems to be
the traditional place to stick annotations about the clarity of
statements.)
CFJ: 3477
Called: 22 Apr 2017
When a statement can be read in an ambiguous way or in a clear way, it
should be read to be clear, absent evidence to the contrary.

Rule: 217
CFJ: 3472
Called: 17 Nov 2016
If a statement is clearly translatable via machine translation (e.g.
Google Translate), it is a sufficiently clear communication for game
purposes.

Rule: 2143
CFJ: 3462
Called: 21 Oct 2016
A inaccurate report is still a report, unless it "exhibit[s] gross
sloppiness and negligence, equivalent in severity to lying in the
report or not publishing it."

Rule: 2160
CFJ: 3462
Called: 21 Oct 2016
In normal deputization, the deputy "actually" gains the office
immediately after deputizing for it.

Reply via email to