I agree all of these should be fixed and made more explicit. Please see below for more details. ---- Publius Scribonius Scholasticus p.scribonius.scholasti...@gmail.com
> On Sep 8, 2017, at 8:49 PM, Ørjan Johansen <oer...@nvg.ntnu.no> wrote: > > On Fri, 8 Sep 2017, Kerim Aydin wrote: > >> I transfer to Agora the Stamp Value, in shinies, to create a Stamp. >> >> I know this is very likely impossible, I'm not trying to mislead anyone. >> >> But if we ratify everything to what would-have-been, I want my cheap stamp. > > I'll just note that the currently awaiting Ratification Without Objection > won't help you here, since it only affects past holdings and doesn't fix the > MAY issue itself. > > Also, I searched for may/MAY in the last posted Ruleset. I found only one > "MAY" people seem still to have missed, but there are a lot of cases where > "may" is used in a way that would break if it were synonymous with "MAY" > rather than "CAN". > > Rule 478 may not enable changing Forum publicity. This is resolved because of ratification of the reports, within which it is included. > > Rule 2493 may not enable enacting/modifying regulations. This is resolved because of ratification of the reports, within which it is included. > > Rule 2500 may not prevent someone going negative AP. This could be a problem. > > Rule 2431 may not prevent more than one simultaneous competition. (Unclear > since it's not really about actions.) This isn’t very important > > Rule 208 and 955 should probably use "can" instead of "may", in principle. > > Rule 991 may not enable barring from judgement. This can be resolved by the Arbitor following the requested earrings. > > Rule 2492 feels like it's probably okay, but still probably should use "CAN". > > Rule 2467 may not enable creating Agencies - that's a "MAY", so I'm a bit > surprised no one seems to have picked up on this. If "may"s are a problem, > amendment, revocation and use is also impossible. This is resolved because of ratification of the reports, within which it is included. > > Rule 2464 may not enable repealing tournament regulations. This is resolved because of ratification of the reports, within which it is included. > > Rule 2491 may not allow bidding on auctions. (Depends on whether a bid is > just an announcement.) This has previously been resolved by ratification, but could still become an issue in the future. > > Rule 2483 makes me queasy. Can I own Shinies, even if I may not? > > Rule 2485 may not enable heir flipping. > > Rule 2480 may not enable flipping Festivity. This is an urgent change, given the nature of the rule. > > Rule 2495 should probably use "can" instead of "may". > > Greetings, > Ørjan.
signature.asc
Description: Message signed with OpenPGP using GPGMail
