Cuddlebeam has nothing to do with these proposals? Please reconsider CFJ 3520 and fix the obvious error.
On Wed, Jul 5, 2017 at 2:24 PM Publius Scribonius Scholasticus < p.scribonius.scholasti...@googlemail.com> wrote: > I find CFJ 3520 TRUE as the proposal was submitted by G., while he was > acting as Cuddlebeam. I find that for instances such as this acting as a > person is equivalent to being that person. Given that no persons other than > Cuddlebeam were included, I find that no coauthors exist for this proposal. > > I find CFJ 3521 FALSE because Quazie did not grant G. authority to specify > a proposal competition through his agency. > ---- > Publius Scribonius Scholasticus > p.scribonius.scholasti...@gmail.com > > > > > On Jun 28, 2017, at 3:07 AM, Alex Smith <ais...@alumni.bham.ac.uk> > wrote: > > > > On Tue, 2017-06-06 at 00:04 +0100, Alex Smith wrote: > >> On Mon, 2017-06-05 at 23:24 +0100, Alex Smith wrote: > >>> On Mon, 2017-06-05 at 15:13 -0700, Kerim Aydin wrote: > >>>> > >>>> Note to Arbitor: this message contains 2 CFJs, below. > >>> > >>> (Note to judges: there are two CFJs assigned to judges in this > >>> message.) > > > > (Note to judges: there are two CFJs reassigned to judges in this > > message.) > > > >>> > >>>> I use the BÖÖ Agency to submit the following proposal, "Throw off Your > >>>> Chains", AI-3, specifying that it is a Competition Proposal for the > >>>> current proposal competition: > >>>> ----------------------------------------------------------------- > >>>> ----- > >>>> WHEREAS: > >>>> The perpetuation of dictatorship is not treating Agora Right Good > >>>> Forever; > >>>> > >>>> and WHEREAS: > >>>> The existence of dictatorship is an anathema, and the presence of > >>>> a current dictatorship in the Rules is a Mess of our own making; > >>>> > >>>> and WHEREAS: > >>>> The persons in power have not made a visible effort to clean up > >>>> said mess, in perhaps hoping that the hoi agorai will remain > >>>> docile, or apathetic; > >>>> > >>>> and WHEREAS: > >>>> such docility, in the long-term, is fully AGAINST OUR NATURE; > >>>> > >>>> BE IT THEREFORE RESOLVED: > >>>> That Rule 2942 (Reward and Delay) is hereby REPEALED. > >>>> ---------------------------------------------------------------------- > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> I CFJ on the following: > >>>> Quazie is the author of the proposal "Throw off Your Chains". > >>> > >>> This is CFJ 3520. I assign it to Gaelan. > > > > I remove Gaelan as judge of this CFJ, and assign it to Publius > > Scribonius Scholasticus. > > > >>>> Evidence: (above proposal & submission statement). > >>>> > >>>> Arguments: > >>>> > >>>> I state for the record that Quazie had no knowledge of this proposal > >>>> before it was sent to the public forum. The proposal was written by > >>>> G., and submitted on behalf of Quazie via the BÖÖ Agency. > >>>> > >>>> Rule 2350 reads in part: > >>>> A player CAN create a proposal by announcement... > >>>> this is clearly Quazie. > >>>> > >>>> But it also reads: > >>>> The author (syn. proposer) of a proposal is the person who > >>>> submitted it. > >>>> "Submit" is not directly defined, and could be the publisher of the > >>>> message. In this case, the sender and writer of the proposal is G. > >>>> Which one is the "person who submitted it"? > >>>> > >>>> ========================== > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> I CFJ on the following (linked to the above, please): > >>>> The proposal "Throw off Your Chains" is a competition proposal > >>>> for the current proposal competition. > >>> > >>> This is CFJ 3521. I assign it to Gaelan. > > > > I remove Gaelan as judge of this CFJ, and assign it to Publius > > Scribonius Scholasticus. > > > >>>> Evidence: (above proposal & submission statement). > >>>> > >>>> Arguments: > >>>> Rule 2431 reads in part: > >>>> any player CAN specify that a Proposal e submits is > >>>> a Competition Proposal for that Competition. > >>>> > >>>> Whether this is in the proposal competition depends on whether > >>>> Quazie "submitted" the proposal, and whether G. had the ability > >>>> through the BÖÖ Agency to specify the competition. > > > > -- > > ais523 > > Arbitor > >
