The idea is that Agora would pay for it, but I see your issue and will
submit a revision soon, if others don't beat me to it.
----
Publius Scribonius Scholasticus
On Mon, May 15, 2017 at 12:38 PM, Alex Smith <ais...@alumni.bham.ac.uk> wrote:
> On Mon, 2017-05-15 at 11:22 -0500, Nic Evans wrote:
>> On 05/15/17 10:57, Alex Smith wrote:
>> > > ais523 CAN Declare an Amendment by announcement, specifying a proposal.
>> > > Upon doing so, that proposal's imminence flips to "pending".
>> >
>> > So as not to stall the game, I'll use this mechanism for people on
>> > request, so long as the proposal being pended is not a scam. However, I
>> > request that a small donation of 5 Shinies be made to Agora in return
>> > for this service, so as not to disrupt the economy.
>>
>> While we have the efficiency of authoritarianism we might as well clean
>> up a couple things. PSS attempted to pend a proposal titled Agora's
>> To-Do List. The Secretary counted the payment but the Promotor didn't
>> add it to the pool or distribute it. I submit the following proposal and
>> request that it be pended:
>>
>> {{{
>> Title: Agora's To-Do List
>> Adoption index: 1.0
>> Author: Publius Scribonius Scholasticus
>>
>> Enact a rule titled, "To-Do List", reading: "Any player MAY with 1
>> support add an item to the to-do list with a specified number of
>> Shinies associated with it. Any to-do list item must have a clear set
>> of requirements for completion. The to-do list shall be maintained by
>> the Lister. Any person MAY complete an item on the to-do list and
>> claim the specified number of Shinies associated with it by notifying
>> the Lister of their completion of the task. If the Lister agrees with
>> the claimee, the Lister shall pay the claimee the specified number of
>> Shinies from Agora. Any disagreement regarding completion shall be
>> resolved via a CFJ. After an item has been completed, the Lister shall
>> remove it from the to-do list."
>>
>> Enact a rule titled, "The Office of the Lister", reading: "The Lister
>> is an office; its holder is responsible for maintaining the to-do of
>> Agora.
>>
>> The Lister's Weekly report includes the current state of the Agoran
>> to-do list and any recent events thereof."
>> }}}
> Part of the pending mechanism is intended to catch problems with
> proposals before they're distributed. There's a fairly clear problem
> with this one (the Lister plus a confederate could scam arbitrarily
> many shinies from Agora via adding a large number of trivial tasks). I
> recommend you retract that proposal and submit one without that issue
> (e.g. via basing the requirements to add things to the to-do list on
> objections rather than support). As this proposal clearly shouldn't
> pass in its current form, pending it seems like a bad idea, although
> I'll gladly give you a free pend for the replacement.
>
> Alternatively, you could charge players Shinies to add items to the
> list, and then give those Shinies to the person who fulfils the task.
> This doesn't even need a rule to implement; you could do it as an
> Organization.
>
>> Additionally, I attempted to pend Granular Paydays (v3) but it wasn't in
>> the most recent Promotor's report, and now I suspect that, regardless of
>> the results of my CoE, it can't be pended that way. So I'd appreciate if
>> that was pended as well, and I'll submit another payment if the
>> Secretary doesn't accept the payment I already made to pend it.
>
> Fair enough. I pend "Granular Paydays (v3)" via the mechanism in the
> rule "Reward and Delay".
>
> --
> ais523
