Pavitra wrote: > On 06/04/2011 03:40 PM, Benjamin Caplan wrote: >> I CFJ: G.'s citizenship switch is a player. > > I retract this. > > > I CFJ: Droowl is a player. > > Arguments: > > By R869 (How to Join and Leave Agora), citizenship is an entity switch; > in particular, Droowl's citizenship has a citizenship switch. > > R2162 (Switches) reads in part as follows: > "To become X" (where X is a possible value of > exactly one of the subject's switches) is to flip that switch to > X. > > Thus, when Droowl attempted to register (that is, to cause eir > citizenship switch to become Registered), e thereby attempted to > register eir citizenship switch along with emself. > > However, R869 says: > A non-person CANNOT be registered (or created in a Registered > state), rules to the contrary notwithstanding. > > Thus, Droowl's attempt to register eir citizenship switch platonically > failed. Since the above-quoted section of R2162 ties "becoming X" > directly to "flipping my Y switch to X", the failure of eir switch to > become Registered resulted in a failure of emself to become Registered. > > Therefore, Droowl is not a player.
Gratuitous: Instances of switches are attributes of entities, not entities in their own right.
