On Sun, 6 Jun 2010, Ed Murphy wrote:
> * I think it's too late for admitting the CoE to nullify the
> entire decision.
Nope: R1607:
For an Agoran decision of whether to adopt a proposal, the
following are essential parameters:
c) Its Chamber.
R107:
An Agoran decision is initiated when a person authorized to
initiate it publishes a valid notice which sets forth the intent
to initiate the decision. This notice is invalid if it lacks
any of the following information, and the lack is correctly
identified within one week after the notice is published:
(e) Any additional information defined by the rules as essential
parameters.
The notice of initiation is auto-invalidated by the noted lack of
correct information here. This is even true if the lack is only
mentioned in a discussion forum (CFJ 2615). The formal CoE should
have prevented the self-ratification of the existence of the decision.
-G.
