I think "has been a player continuously for X" is supposed to mean "is a player, and has been so continuously for X". e.g. if I deregister, I wouldn't say "I've been a player of Agora for three months."

Sent from my iPhone

On Nov 24, 2009, at 11:19 AM, Kerim Aydin <ke...@u.washington.edu> wrote:


On Tue, 24 Nov 2009, Kerim Aydin wrote:
                                       When a first-class person
         has been a player continuously for at least three months,
         was never a player before that period, and names another
         player as eir mentor (and has not named a mentor in this
         fashion before), the named player earns a White Ribbon.

This seems to grandfather in everyone who was a player before the
rule came to have this form.

-G.

To be precise:
 I was (had been) a player from Feb 2001-May 2001.
 I was never a player before that period.
 I have never named a mentor.
I name Taral as my Mentor. I create a white ribbon in eir possession.

I call the following CFJ:  Taral has earned a white ribbon.

Evidence:

G. wrote:
To be precise:
 I was (had been) a player from Feb 2001-May 2001.
 I was never a player before that period.
 I have never named a mentor.
 I name Taral as my Mentor.

From Rule 2199/8:
     (+W) When a first-class person becomes a player for the first
          time, e earns a White Ribbon.  When a first-class person
          has been a player continuously for at least three months,
          was never a player before that period, and names another
          player as eir mentor (and has not named a mentor in this
          fashion before), the named player earns a White Ribbon.

-G.

Reply via email to