ehird wrote: > 2009/6/5 Kerim Aydin <ke...@u.washington.edu>: >> On Fri, 5 Jun 2009, Elliott Hird wrote: >>> 2009/6/5 Ed Murphy <emurph...@socal.rr.com>: >>>> "Legitimately" as in you overlooked a message? >>>> >>>> http://www.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-official/2009-May/006402.html >>> Arguments on yonder CFJ: Yes; I do look hawkishly for CFJ assignments >>> but I may have been tired and forgotten it afterwards. I do not mind a >>> penalty, I just don't think two Rests is just. >> You should clarify that you're saying "mea culpa - Guilty - but missing >> a message when I don't have a history of doing so doesn't deserve a 2-blot >> sentence." Â -G. > > Arguments: mea culpa - Guilty - but missing > a message when I don't have a history of doing so doesn't deserve a 2-blot > sentence.
Gratuitous evidence: Here is a list of every case to which ehird has been assigned as a judge or panelist, and eir approximate response time or lack thereof: 1925 recused 11h 1932 judged 11h 1933 recused 14d 2134 recused 3w 2333 recused 11.5d 2344 judged 6.5d 2357 recused 10h 2402 judged 1h / judged 4d 2405 recused 12d 2412 judged 1d 2423 judged 20m 2424 judged 20m / judged 3d / recused 14d 2425 judged 20m / judged 3d / recused 14d 2441 judged 1h 2447 judged 5m 2457 recused 15m 2460 judged 18h 2469 judged 10m 2477 recused 8h 2484 judged 1.5h 2499 judged 10m 2500 judged 15m 2521 recused 15d 1937a supported 9.5d 2101a recused 3w 2437a no opinion given 2454b supported 1d 2494a opined 3h 2524a opined 2.5h so e does have some history of non-judgement (for whatever reasons), though some others during the past few years have been worse (prompting legislation to allow and/or require the CotC to make em supine).
