coppro wrote: > Ed Murphy wrote: >> coppro wrote: >> >>> Ed Murphy wrote: >>>> Rule 1504, in the section on SILENCE: "The judge CAN, with 2 Support, >>>> set the fine" etc. >>> I'm not the judge yet, unless I missed the announcement. >> R1728(c)(1) allows the judge to do it; R1728(c)(3) allows one of the >> supporters to do it, since R1504 doesn't explicitly say otherwise. > Neither you nor I is, or ever was, authorized to perform this action, > since neither of us, at any time, have been the judge of that case. > > Also, I think you couldn't perform it unless we were simultaneously the > judge, as R1728(a) would never be satisfied at the same time as R1728(c)(3).
Oh, I think you're right, I'm used to "any player CAN <action>" for which R1728(a) is trivially satisfied.
