On Sun, 19 Apr 2009, Sean Hunt wrote: > Kerim Aydin wrote: >> On Sun, 19 Apr 2009, Sean Hunt wrote: >>> Those castes are at their correct values, despite some of the flips I >>> made being illegal. >> >> I agree that they are the accurate current values. But you are required >> to un-do any flips that you performed illegally, in that sense they are >> not what would be "correct" if your caste flips had been legal. From R2211: >> >> If the result of a claim of error or court case >> finds that e has flipped a Player's caste illegally (e.g. not >> as specified by the Rules), e SHALL flip the caste to the >> appropriate correct value as soon as possible. >> >> In this context, "correct" clearly means "following the court case, what the >> castes should have been if no illegal flips had been performed. >> >> -Goethe > > I believe that the only flip you succeeded in doing was Billy Pilgrim to > Alpha, so all my flips failed except flipping em to Beta. I later undid > this flip.
Why weren't each of the single promotions to beta, gamma and delta, I performed legal? They were surrounded by attempted, failed actions but that didn't make them less legal or performable. I did: I flip B.P. to alpha. (a bunch of failed attempted flips to alpha) I flip j to beta (e was gamma at the time, so fit the pattern). (a bunch of failed attempted flips to beta) I flip cmealerjr to gamma (e was delta at the time, so fit the pattern). (a bunch of failed attempted flips to gamma) I flip BobTHJ to delta (e was epsilon at the time, so fit the pattern). (a bunch of failed attempted flips to delta) So all of those four should have been put back, followed by demotions taking into account these positions. -G.
