On Fri, Jul 18, 2008 at 10:07 AM, ais523 <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Either the contents of this message affect the outcome of a CFJ such as > 2069, or they don't. In the case that the contents do affect the > outcome, this means that the publishing of the message itself was a > game-relevant action, because it affected the outcome of the CFJ; > therefore, whatever the contents of the message, the CFJ is going to be > ruled FALSE (i.e. TRUE that there is a game-relevant action)
I don't believe that follows. The fact that publishing of a message *is* a game-relevant action does not imply that the message *contains* a game-relevant action (a message does not contain its own publication, which is an action of a physical nature). -root
