On Thu, Jul 17, 2008 at 10:09 AM, Kerim Aydin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > On Thu, 17 Jul 2008, Quazie wrote: >> So if CFJs 2073, 2019, 2080, and 2079 weren't actually CFJs, does that >> make the rotations of the bench that happened after judges were >> assigned to these cases invalid? Meaning, if they don't exist, then >> they weren't judged. If they weren't judged, then they couldn't have >> become sitting by judging. Thus the CotC rotated the bench with a >> standing member. Either that or E made a judge sitting at an >> incorrect time. > > No, rotating at the wrong time is illegal but not impossible, R1871: > The CotC CAN rotate the bench (change all sitting players to > standing) by announcement, but SHALL NOT do so unless ... > > -Goethe >
So if any of those end up not being CFJs there is a criminal case against the CotC
