On Tue, Apr 29, 2008 at 12:59 AM, Kerim Aydin <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> > On Mon, 28 Apr 2008, Ed Murphy wrote: > > Detail: http://zenith.homelinux.net/cotc/viewcase.php?cfj=1931 > > > > ============================== CFJ 1931 ============================== > > > > IRCNomic is a public contract. > > > > ======================================================================== > > To be an Agoran public contract, a governing document must first be an > Agoran contract. Not all contracts in the universe are automatically > recognized by Agora as Agoran contracts: to be so recognized, its members > must enter it "with the intention that it be binding on them and governed > by > [Agoran] rules." (R1742). > > If the members of the contract didn't intend it to be binding under Agoran > rules, it is not an Agoran contract, though it may be a contract under > other jurisdictions. If it is not an Agoran contract, R2178 (Public > Contracts) does not apply to it. > > In the discussion forum, ais523 wrote: > > I am an Agoran, and also a player of IRCnomic. However, I have not (from > an > > Agoran point of view) knowingly joined comex's contract, if it is one. > Many > > IRCnomic rules conflict with Agoran rules anyway. (Doesn't Agora define > > Player differently, for instance?) > > Given this statement, and the contract rights contained in R101(iv) and > (v), > I find that the burden of proof is on the caller (or others) to explicitly > provide evidence refuting ais523's statement, e.g. to provide evidence > that > ais523 either intended IRCnomic to be binding under Agoran rules or that e > explicitly signed away eir rights to make the decision. I post this > publicly > to give the caller 4 days to provide such evidence, while pointing out > that > even if proof is provided, the quality of the evidence must be extremely > high > (e.g. recorded w/headers statements showing ais523's intent, a recanting > from > ais523 (as the statement was not a public statement) or that ais523 > directly > and knowingly ceded this right through the contract's mechanisms). > > -Goethe I don't know if this is useful, but IRCnomic logs are at http://elliotthird.org:8080/logs/ Also, I personally never agreed for IRCnomic to become an Agoran public contract, but as I am not currently a player of Agora, I don't know how much that counts for.
