Geoffrey Spear wrote:
On Jan 30, 2008 3:02 PM, Roger Hicks <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
Making the public statement 'This statement is a lie' would
cause the person making that statement to violate Rule 2149.
Soliciting comments on this CFJ.
Judge BobTHJ
I agree with H. Zefram's analysis. Rule 2149 forbids a player from
making statements that e does not believe to be true; presumably any
player would not believe that statement to be true.
Well, if the player making that statement believed it wasn't true, then
that statement would be a lie, which is what the statement says?
If the rule instead prohibited players from making statements that
they believed to be false, making such a statement wouldn't, IMO, be a
violation since presumably a reasonable player would not consider the
given statement to be false.
--Wooble
Levi
