On Mon, 31 Dec 2007, Ed Murphy wrote:
> Goethe wrote:
>> On Tue, 25 Dec 2007, Ed Murphy wrote:
>>> All AGAINST votes in this message are cast only on the condition that
>>> the proposal in question would meet quorum even if I didn't vote on it.
>> 
>> Interesting.  Technically, this isn't known "within" the voting period
>> but only at the endpoint.  R2127 probably doesn't let it work.  You can
>> probably get around it by something trivial like "if quorum hasn't been
>> met 10^-14 seconds before the end of voting period".  -Goethe
>
> The determination doesn't need to be within the voting period, only the
> published information on which it is based.

But you can't figure out if the proposal "would meet quorum" until the moment
after the voting period has ended.  -Goethe



Reply via email to